Nurses' leadership in psychiatric care—A qualitative interview study of nurses' experience of leadership in an adult psychiatric inpatient care setting

Abstract

Accessible Summary What is known on the subject? Previous studies on leadership in psychiatric care have focussed on a diversity of staff and on different healthcare settings. Nurses in both Sweden and internationally, working with patients newly diagnosed with psychosis and addiction, describe an overwhelming workload. Existing research points out that experience and leadership training are the most important factors to exert a good nursing leadership. In Sweden, requirements for leadership exists already from the first day of a nurse's career. The relationship and communication between nurses in psychiatric care and members of the staff is decisive for whether the leadership will work. What the paper adds to existing knowledge The study adds knowledge regarding the challenges leading the nursing care for patients diagnosed with psychosis and addiction. Ambivalence in the leadership role is prominent among nurses in psychiatric care and feelings of responsibility and meaningfulness are mixed with feelings of powerlessness and uncertainty. Swedish psychiatric nurses lack mandate to lead psychiatric nursing care. This may increase the feelings of uncertainty in their leadership role. What are the implications for practice? A mandate to lead as well as a leadership guidance in communication and teambuilding will enhance the leadership, especially among newly graduated nurses. Heightened awareness within the healthcare organization about nurse's experience of difficulties in leading the psychiatric nursing care of the most severe psychiatric illnesses could increase the right prerequisites for leadership. Abstract IntroductionResearch shows that psychiatric nursing care puts additional demands on the nurse as a leader due to the psychological complexity of care. Experience and leadership training are most important to exert leadership. In Sweden, demands for leadership exist already at the beginning of a nursing career, and in psychiatry, it may lead to an overwhelming workload. Aim/QuestionThe aim of the present study is to highlight nurses' experiences of leading the psychiatric nursing care in an adult psychiatric context. MethodA qualitative interview study of eleven registered nurses within psychiatric inpatient care. Content analysis was used for analysis. ResultsLeading with combined feelings of both meaningfulness and uncertainty were the theme arising from the result. DiscussionFindings from Swedish and international studies stress special demands on leadership in psychiatric care. The result shows that nurses perceived an ambivalence of their leadership in terms of both meaningfulness and uncertainty. Implications for PracticeAn official mandate to lead as well as leadership guidance in communication and teambuilding will enhance leadership, especially among newly graduated nurses. Heightened awareness within healthcare organizations about difficulties in leading psychiatric nursing care could increase the possibility to create right prerequisites for leadership.

Registered nurses’ challenges and suggestions for improvement of their leadership close to older adults in municipal home healthcare

“…The RNs in this study suggested improving their leadership by regularly receiving education on leadership. This result is in line with Sundberg et al [ 50 ], who found that RNs leading in psychiatric care wanted more leadership training to be able to lead nursing care. RNs in municipalities are expected to have leadership competence [ 53 , 54 ].…”

“…Managers are not always familiar with RNs’ work in home healthcare, due to different educational backgrounds [ 48 ]. Managers’ support has been described as important for RNs to perceive themselves as leaders [ 50 ]. Therefore, in home healthcare, where RNs as leaders have an important and complex role that implies a wide range of challenges, they need managers’ support.…”

Leadership and community healthcare reform: a study using the Competing Values Framework (CVF)

“…Moreover, in clinical practice, mentoring and incentives are required to ensure that what was learned will be consistently applied. Very often health-care organisations support training but provide little opportunities to put what is learned into practice ( Smyth et al , 2020 ; Sundberg et al , 2021 ). This is not surprising because the hierarchical leadership tradition, which dominates global health care often does not stimulate those not in management positions to show leadership ( Francis, 2013 ; Yuseon and Jiyeon, 2016 ).…”

Solving the shortage of psychiatric – mental health nurses in acute inpatient care settings

“…We believe that enhanced focus upon and support for local unit leadership and line management is needed. Flexible approaches, person-centred leadership, and support all aid retention (Sundberg et al, 2021)…”