Nurse home visiting to improve child and maternal outcomes: 5-year follow-up of an Australian randomised controlled trial

Abstract

Objectives Nurse home visiting (NHV) is widely implemented to address inequities in child and maternal health. However, few studies have examined longer-term effectiveness or delivery within universal healthcare systems. We evaluated the benefits of an Australian NHV program (“right@home”) in promoting children’s language and learning, general and mental health, maternal mental health and wellbeing, parenting and family relationships, at child ages 4 and 5 years. Setting and participants Randomised controlled trial of NHV delivered via universal, child and family health services (the comparator). Pregnant women experiencing adversity (≥2 of 10 risk factors) were recruited from 10 antenatal clinics across 2 states (Victoria, Tasmania) in Australia. Intervention Mothers in the intervention arm were offered 25 nurse home visits (mean 23·2 home visits [SD 7·4, range 1–43] received) of 60–90 minutes, commencing antenatally and continuing until children’s second birthdays. Primary and secondary outcomes measured At 4 and 5 years, outcomes were assessed via parent interview and direct assessment of children’s language and learning (receptive and expressive language, phonological awareness, attention, and executive function). Outcomes were compared between intervention and usual care arms (intention to treat) using adjusted regression with robust estimation to account for nurse/site. Missing data were addressed using multiple imputation and inverse probability weighting. Results Of 722 women enrolled in the trial, 225 of 363 (62%) intervention and 201 of 359 (56%) usual care women provided data at 5 years. Estimated group differences showed an overall pattern favouring the intervention. Statistical evidence of benefits was found across child and maternal mental health and wellbeing, parenting and family relationships with effect sizes ranging 0·01–0·27. Conclusion An Australian NHV program promoted longer-term family functioning and wellbeing for women experiencing adversity. NHV can offer an important component of a proportionate universal system that delivers support and intervention relative to need. Trial registration 2013–2016, registration ISRCTN89962120

Embedding nurse home visiting in universal healthcare: 6-year follow-up of a randomised trial

“…As per the trial’s programme logic, the early benefits to parent care, responsivity and the home learning environment that were evident at 2 years12 appear to be translating into gains for child outcomes at 6 years. Although benefits to maternal mental health that were previously evident at 3–5 years10 11 were not apparent at 6 years, benefits for measures of parenting, maternal well-being and family relationships were sustained from the preschool years.…”

“…Recognising the importance of tailoring programmes to maximise impact,9 the structure incorporated evidence-based interventions (‘focus modules’), which are customisable to local subpopulations. Follow-up from 2 to 5 years demonstrated wide-ranging benefits across domains including parenting, the home environment and maternal mental health 10–12…”

The Impact of COVID-19 Related Distress on Antenatal Depression in Australia

“…Extending access to programs such as sustained nurse home visiting, that support families with health, education, and early parenting beginning in pregnancy may be one way to combat some of these issues. Evidence for nurse home visiting programs is substantial [ 63 , 64 ]. Studies of such programs show families who participate report considerable parenting, social, and health benefits as much as five years later, indicating the programs can provide valuable lifelong improvement to the well-being of families.…”

The social determinants of mental health and disorder: evidence, prevention and recommendations

“…Given the importance of the prenatal period in shaping men tal, physical and cognitive trajectories, providing goodquality and accessible parental and familial support early in life is essential to affect this process 367 . Earlier, we presented evidence of posi tive outcomes following earlylife home visitation programs for pregnant and postpartum mothers, with benefits extending into childhood and adolescence, and huge cost savings 371,373 . These in terventions are particularly effective in selective groups.…”

“…This intervention continued to exhibit marked divi dends into adolescence, through reduced welfare and justice sys tem involvement 372 . A similar intervention study in Australia, that also included monthly nurse home visits for the first two years of the child's life, showed that children of mothers who received nurse visits had overall lower scores on the Strengths and Difficul ties Questionnaire, indicating fewer emotional and behavioural problems 373 . Interestingly, the same study showed positive out comes for parents across a wide range of domains, including less hostility, less parentchild conflict, higher wellbeing and qual ity of life, and increased selfefficacy.…”