Nudging is Ineffective When Attitudes Are Unsupportive: An Example from a Natural Field Experiment

Abstract

For security reasons, employees of a Dutch local government department needed to wear an identifying lanyard with their employee badge, but compliance with this policy was low. Two nudges to increase compliance were evaluated in a pre-registered natural field experiment using a pre-post design, and a qualitative survey. Bayesian inference provides insufficient support for the effectiveness of the nudges. While more respondents judged the nudges and the lanyard policy positively than negatively, there was substantial negative judgment and incomprehension for both with some employees finding the nudges paternalistic. We hypothesize that the nudges were ineffective because they failed to change attitudes about the policy, and because they led to reactance among some employees. Implications for nudging within organizations are discussed.

Persuading republicans and democrats to comply with mask wearing: An intervention tournament

“…Given that none of the seven interventions worked, we need to continue to develop more ecologically valid interventions to help promote mask wearing and social distancing as the pandemic continues to evolve. As research shows, behavior change with light-touch interventions is particularly challenging when individual attitudes are already unsupportive to begin with ( Dewies, Schop-Etman, Rohde, & Denktaş, 2021 ), which was the case for Republicans in our sample.…”

Nudging People to Pay Their Parking Fines on Time. Evidence from a Cluster-Randomized Field Experiment

“…Consequently, with these results, we add evidence to the growing body of nudge literature suggesting that the relationship between nudge outputs and behavioral outcomes is complex. Nudge interventions and nudge combinations may work under certain conditions, but their effectiveness is characterized by heterogeneity across policy domains, nudge types, populations segments, baseline attitudes, geographical locations and targeted behaviors (Dewies et al, 2021;Holzmeister et al, 2022;Osman et al, 2020;Szaszi et al, 2018Szaszi et al, , 2022. The mixed, contradictory and uncertain results of individual nudges and the struggle to confirm theoretical predictions about deterrence and non-deterrence nudges support our view that behavioral-based policy interventions can be compounded (Vainre et al, 2020) and should be grounded in a practice-oriented design which takes the specific local context into consideration (Van Ryzin, 2021).…”

Applying Behavioural Insights to Public Policy: An Example From Rotterdam

“…Beyond nudges, BIG'R for instance suggested a participatory programme to define a code of conduct for the use of electric charging stations (see supplementary material). Whenever possible, BIG'R tested (some aspects of) the proposed interventions in the field using both quantitative and qualitative methods (e.g., Dewies et al, 2021).…”