NUDGE, SHOVE, BUDGE, SLUDGE AND ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN: Terminological Demarcation and Practical Implications

Abstract

In this paper, the authors provide a precise terminological demarcation of the following behavioral concepts: “nudge”, “shove”, and “budge”. Based on these concepts and three defined criteria (freedom/coercion, internalities/externalities, and behavioral insights), the authors explain various behavioral public policies and their practical implications: 1) the behavioral public policy of libertarian-paternalistic orientation (the “nudge policy”); 2) the policy of coercive paternalism; and 3) the behavioral regulation of externalities. Then, the authors provide a terminological distinction between the concept of “sludge” and “nudge”, and discuss their potential misuses. Finally, based on the level of “frictions”, the authors distinguish between the concepts of “administrative burden” and “sludge”, as well as the types of public policies that are recommended for their reduction, particularly “sludge audits”. The conclusion is that all these public policies are very close, slightly different in terms of the subject matter of regulation and the intensity of encroachment on the freedoms of individuals, but that they all have a common root in behavioral insights.

Untitled

“…Otros estudios destacan el uso de enfoques más paternalistas. Los budges y shoves (Mojašević y Nikolić, 2022;Oliver, 2018;Sunstein, 2013) utilizan las ciencias del comportamiento para ofrecer alternativas de regulación en las políticas públicas. Los budges son intervenciones regulatorias desplegadas por el sector público (Oliver, 2013) que están basadas en la economía del comportamiento y dirigidas a influir en el comportamiento de las empresas privadas.…”

Fighting gender violence with behavioral public policy: scope and limitations

“…Otros estudios destacan el uso de enfoques más paternalistas. Los budges y shoves (Mojašević y Nikolić, 2022;Oliver, 2018;Sunstein, 2013) utilizan las ciencias del comportamiento para ofrecer alternativas de regulación en las políticas públicas. Los budges son intervenciones regulatorias desplegadas por el sector público (Oliver, 2013) que están basadas en la economía del comportamiento y dirigidas a influir en el comportamiento de las empresas privadas.…”