The consensus substrate site for cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) is Arg-Arg-Xaa-Ser(P)-Xaa and the autoinhibitory domain of the PKA type I alpha regulatory subunit (RI subunit) contains a similar sequence, Arg92-Arg-Arg-Arg-Gly-Ala-Ile-Ser-Ala-Glu. The italicized amino acids form a putative pseudosubstrate site (Ser is replaced with Ala), which together with adjacent residues could competitively inhibit substrate phosphorylation by the PKA catalytic subunit (C subunit). The present studies determine the contributions of Arg92-95, Ile98, and Glu101 to inhibitory potency. Amino-terminal truncation of RI subunit through Arg92 (delta1-92) or Arg93 (delta1-93) had no detectable effect on inhibition of C subunit. Truncation through Arg94 (delta1-94), or point mutation of Arg95 within truncated mutants (delta1-93.R95A or delta1-92.R95A), caused a dramatic reduction in inhibitory potency. Truncation through Arg95 (delta1-95) had a greater effect than did replacement or deletion of Arg94 or Arg95 alone. Using full-length RI subunit, the inhibitory potency was reduced by replacing Ile98 with Ala, Gly, or Gln, but not by replacing it with Val. The inhibitory potency of RI subunit was unchanged when Glu101 was replaced with Ala or Gln. It is concluded that Arg94, Arg95 and, to a lesser extent, Ile98 are vital constituents of PKA autoinhibition by type I alpha R subunit.