The Root effect is a widespread property among fish hemoglobins whose structural basis remains largely obscure. Here we report a crystallographic and spectroscopic characterization of the non-Root-effect hemoglobin isolated from the Antarctic fish Trematomus newnesi in the deoxygenated form. The crystal structure unveils that the T state of this hemoglobin is stabilized by a strong H-bond between the side chains of Asp95␣ and Asp101 at the ␣ 1  2 and ␣ 2  1 interfaces. This unexpected finding undermines the accepted paradigm that correlates the presence of this unusual H-bond with the occurrence of the Root effect. Surprisingly, the T state is characterized by an atypical flexibility of two ␣ chains within the tetramer. Indeed, regions such as the CD␣ corner and the EF␣ pocket, which are normally well ordered in the T state of tetrameric hemoglobins, display high B-factors and non-continuous electron densities. This flexibility also leads to unusual distances between the heme iron and the proximal and distal His residues. These observations are in line with Raman micro-spectroscopy studies carried out both in solution and in the crystal state. The findings here presented suggest that in fish hemoglobins the Root effect may be switched off through a significant destabilization of the T state regardless of the presence of the inter-aspartic H-bond. Similar mechanisms may also operate for other non-Root effect hemoglobins. The implications of the flexibility of the CD␣ corner for the mechanism of the T-R transition in tetrameric hemoglobins are also discussed.Protein crystallography is a fundamental tool to interpret protein function at atomic level. Although this approach is usually effective in understanding the general trends of biological processes, it is often difficult to single out the structural details important for their fine regulation. The case of hemoglobin (Hb) 2 is emblematic in this context. Since the pioneering studies by Perutz, the basic features of Hb function (identification of distinct quaternary states, transitions between these states, etc.) have been elucidated at atomic level. However, the identification of the structural features at the basis of the different properties of Hbs, isolated from organisms living under different conditions, has proven to be highly elusive. In this framework, the so-called Root effect represents one of the most puzzling issues.The Root effect, first described in 1931, is a peculiar property of some fish Hbs that is associated with an extremely low affinity for oxygen at low pH values (1, 2). Notably, at oxygen partial pressures adequate to saturate most of vertebrate Hbs, Rooteffect Hbs generally remain in a deoxygenated state at acidic pH values. The Root effect has been functionally related to the filling of the fish swim bladder with gas and to the supply of oxygen to the typically un-capillarized fish retina (3). Although the physiology and the structural basis of the Root effect have been addressed in a large number of studies (2-8), it remains a myst...