“…As already mentioned, the original work describing the preparation of dsp-1 did not indicate the opening of the compound under acidic conditions, 41 and the more recent report of a closely related analogue of 1·H + did not identify either the dicationic or spirocyclic forms of the dye at low and high pH conditions, respectively. 40 In our case, the cationic or dispiropyran forms of compounds 1 and 2 were successfully isolated using either acidic or basic treatment of the reaction and both forms could be easily differentiated. Firstly, the appearance of compounds 1 and 2 in solution markedly varies from green for the cationic species to colourless for the less conjugated dispiropyrans.…”