Norwegian midwives’ opinion of their midwifery education – a mixed methods study

Abstract

BackgroundMidwifery education in Norway has undergone radical reforms in the past few decades. In 2004, the compulsory year of paid internship was removed from the requirement to become an authorised midwife. Since then, authorisation as a midwife depends on the successful completion of a two-year full-time academic course, consisting of 50% clinical practice and 50% theoretical education. Our objective was to examine midwives’ opinion of their Norwegian midwifery education in relation to their midwifery practice, comparing those educated with internship to those without.MethodsWe performed a mixed-methods study based on data from a nationwide cross-sectional survey. A sample of 547 midwives completed a postal questionnaire, autumn 2014. Midwives were asked how they were educated, how their education prepared them for practice (multiple choice) and to freely comment on their midwifery education. Thematic analysis and descriptive and comparative analysis was used. Data sets were analysed independently and jointly interpreted.ResultsOf our sample, 154 (28.2%) were educated through a two-year midwifery education without internship, while 393 (71.8%) had a one-year midwifery education with internship. Compared to midwives who had internship, midwives without were four times more likely to report that their education did not, or only partially prepare them for their work as a midwife. The association lost its significance when adjusted for experience as a midwife. According to the qualitative data, the primary reason for the association was insufficient clinical practice during education. Relevant clinical placement, ample practice time with good preceptorship and internship were proposed as methods to prepare for practice as a midwife. The theory–practice gap was highlighted as another hindrance to being prepared for practice.ConclusionsAcademisation of the midwifery education has resulted in newly qualified midwives feeling less prepared for practice. Midwives would have liked more time for clinical practice and simulation training of core midwifery clinical skills included in the education. Midwifery educations need to explore ways to achieve a good balance between practice and theory. Workplaces need to explore alternative ways to internship to assist new graduates to become confident midwives with a strong midwifery identity.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12909-017-0917-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Home birth integration into the health care systems of eleven international jurisdictions

“…In British Columbia, the Netherlands, New Zealand, and Ontario, basic midwifery education requires completion of a 4‐year, direct‐entry, baccalaureate degree in midwifery . In Iceland, Japan, Norway, and Sweden, students complete a baccalaureate nursing degree and then postgraduate studies in midwifery or nurse‐midwifery—further details are provided in Table . Australia, England, and Washington State have multiple educational pathways.…”

Stress, stressors and related factors in clinical learning of midwifery students in Iran: a cross sectional study

“…Lukasse et al showed that many midwives have a negative view to midwifery instructors who have not been in clinical practice for many years or who are not up-to-date in clinical practice. Old and outdated teaching methods lead to a gap between theory and practice [42].…”

Satisfaction with simulation-based education among Bachelor of Midwifery students in public universities and colleges in Harar and Dire Dawa cities, Ethiopia

“…High-quality patient care is only feasible if midwives have received high-quality teaching during their course of study and working years. Current education methods related to the theoretical and practical training of midwives can help them to recognize and manage better patients' needs by means of simulated cases 4,5 .…”

“…Simulation-based education can create a specific learning environment to ensure midwifery students manage their experiential learning by reinforcing clinical skills through different levels of competency. In both undergraduate teaching and post-registration education, simulation is increasingly being used as a teaching tool within midwifery to teach both emergency situations and practice skills 5,6 .…”