Normative identity processes in managers' personal development training

Abstract

PurposeThe article aims to analyze how personal development training influences managers' identity processes.Design/methodology/approachThe article, taking an interpretive‐critical approach, is based on a qualitative, longitudinal study of five participants (managers) in a personal development training program. During the two years of research, 62 interviews (with the managers and related personnel) were conducted and 13 observations were made.FindingsPersonal development training provokes identity regulation by prescribing a normative identity process that claims managers should engage in a process of reflection in order to gain self‐awareness. Such training constitutes a local management discourse that may influence different levels of identity work and identity regulation processes depending on the participants' expectations, their organizations and professional situations, their level of insecurity, as well as their previous experience with management discourse.Practical implicationsSince management training influences participants' identity processes, program organizers, purchasers and participants should be wary of the expectation that management training will deliver content as “a package” of managerial skills.Originality/valueThe study challenges the traditional view of management training as a provider of skills and solutions for managers by focusing instead on its influence on managers' processes of identity work and identity regulation. Management training in general is claimed to regulate identities and direct identity work by providing inspirational identities. However, this study finds that personal development training regulates identities by prescribing the identity process in itself.

Integrating Herzberg and Social Exchange Theories to Underpinned Human Resource Practices, Leadership Style and Employee Retention in Health Sector

“…Most organizations may use career management programs to assist their employees to properly plan their careers because it is believed that, generally, employees react positively to career development and advancement opportunities. According to Andersson (2012), training & development (R&D) constitutes a local management discourse that may affect different levels of work identity, such as personal development, self-knowledge and personal growth. Bitner and Zeithmal (2004) conclude that expenditure on training leads to the competitive advantage of an organization.…”

Enabling Social Identity Interaction: Bulgarian Migrant Entrepreneurs Building Embeddedness into a Transnational Network

“…‘In identity work the actor uses discourse as a tool, while in identity regulation discourse ties people to social structures using roles, scripts, etc.’ (Andersson, , p. 575). Figure illustrates the data drawn from Bulgarian entrepreneurs at different stages of embeddedness.…”

Open, transparent management and the media: The managers’ perspectives

“…These findings are in line with another recent, longitudinal study about growth of authenticity in managers as a consequence of adversities during a merger [18] and theories of the development of inner strength. [19] Therefore, the development of managers' identity is influenced by combined organizational and managerial processes, [20] their dealing with contradictory and conflicting logics [21] and the adversities they face. The development of identity through a struggle between personal identity and being a representative…”

“…[10,20,21] This study contributes by describing how mobilization of resources triggered the development of authenticity and wider awareness in the interviewed managers' leadership and in the reporting of their HCS through their dealings with the news media, and through development of practices related to open management.…”