“…However, as shown in Figure c, the F dependence of T / T 0 in region (i) at different Δ t values resulted in relatively linear decreases without any threshold behaviors, regardless of the probe photon energy (the results monitored under other photon energy are shown in Figure S3 in the Supporting Information). In different cases of PIPTs, the fluence dependence of the change in physical properties, such as reflectivity, and conductivity, exhibits a threshold behavior. ,,,, In this study, we cannot provide any decisive evidence of the reversible transformation between the β- and α-MnTe other than the similarity of the spectral shape in Figure a and the inset in Figure b. The result in Figure a may be simply ascribed to the response of β-MnTe, and it may not be related to a phase transformation.…”