NONSELF HELP: How Immunology Might Reframe the Enlightenment

Abstract

The classical immunological paradigm is predicated on the body's ability to recognize and eliminate “nonself.” However, the “self–nonself” model has yet to facilitate any resolution of the field's major concerns, and may thus prove to be of limited use. Merely discarding it is no solution, as the juxtaposition of “self” and “nonself” persists in research, in clinical settings, and in everyday practice despite the best efforts of theoretical immunologists. Instead, the very conception of “selfhood” may prove to be key. Replacing immunology's prior and persistent “self” with less static concepts derived from non‐Western contexts not only resolves immunology's famous paradoxes but also offers a new and more accurate model that allows immunology to reframe what may become an outmoded Enlightenment construct of “self.” In such a new paradigm, immunology's well‐known system of protection and defense is replaced with a view in which nonself becomes less the body's enemy than its primary mechanism for the creative assimilation of difference. This incorporative model—in which the “immune system” functions more as a search engine than as an expeller of difference—both resolves outstanding paradoxes, and complies more accurately with contemporary knowledge and research practice. [medical anthropology, immunology, identity]

More than one world, more than one health: Re-configuring interspecies health

“…Indeed, contact, movement and communication (or the sharing of a 'munus' which is itself conditional for the generation of immunity) (Esposito, 2011) all re-emerge in the practices of making life safe. Likewise, as is the case for disease surveillance and understanding, farming practice is not so much a matter of a single world or universe of self-identical objects, which collide and cause effects, but a complex of objects that can both attack and condition life (Napier, 2012). Farming pigs safely is likewise not only about establishing boundaries and excluding microbes, of halting transmission, but requires an approach to health that patches together or manages (in the sense of caring for and continuously monitoring and adjusting) life.…”

Getting Ahead of One’s Self?: The Common Culture of Immunology and Philosophy

“…As a humanist, he thought it timely to "reconsider immunology's contribution to the metaphysics of identity." 20 Known for his practice of "deconstructing" or complicating the binary logic of conventional philosophy, adept at revealing how the excluded other comes to haunt even supposedly pure or "unscathed" objects, Jacques Derrida discovered autoimmunity in the early 1990s. In Specters of Marx, the roguish philosopher observed: "To protect its life, to constitute itself as unique living ego, to relate, as the same, to itself, it [the ego] is necessarily led to welcome the other within .…”

On Precariousness and the Ethical Imagination: The Year 2012 in Sociocultural Anthropology

“…Anthropologists in 2012 built on this disciplinary strength through studies of kinship and mobility (Gay Y Blasco ; Olwig ; Rytter ); interspecies relationality (Shir‐Vertesh ; Nading ; Napier ); and friendship (Ho ). Marshall Sahlins takes us back to an archanthropological point in his witty critique of Warren Shapiro's thesis that kinship extends outward “from the position of the Ego” and his or her “primary,” “elementary,” or “true” kin toward forms of secondary relationality (Sahlins :673).…”