Nonpharmacological Interventions for Cancer‐Related Fatigue: A Systematic Review and Bayesian Network Meta‐Analysis

Abstract

Background: Nonpharmacological interventions are the first recommendation for cancerrelated fatigue, according to current guidelines. There are many forms of nonpharmacological interventions for addressing cancer-related fatigue, but the preferred means remain controversial and are not stated in the guidelines. Therefore, we evaluated the comparative effects and ranks of all major nonpharmacological interventions, according to different assessment methods, in cancer patients with fatigue.Methods: Medline, Embase, Cochrane Library, and Allied and Complementary Medicine Database were searched for randomized controlled trials on nonpharmacological treatments for cancer-related fatigue. We assessed the trials' methodological quality using the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool. A Bayesian network meta-analysis and a comparative effects ranking were performed with Aggregate Data Drug Information System software.Results: A total of 16,675 items were obtained from the databases, and 182 studies comprising 18,491 participants were included in the analysis. Based on the ranking probabilities, multimodal therapy and qigong ranked best with a Brief Fatigue Inventory; for a Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-fatigue scale, combined psychosocial therapies and bright white light therapy ranked best; for the Piper Fatigue Scale, resistance exercise and mindfulness-based stress reduction ranked best; for a multidimensional fatigue inventory, multimodal therapy and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) ranked best; for the European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire (EORTC QLQ-C30), acupuncture and CBT ranked best; and for the Profile of Mood States Fatigue Subscale, multimodal therapy, qigong, aerobic exercise, and CBT ranked best. Comprehensive analysis of the results indicated that multimodal therapy, CBT, and qigong might be the optimum selections for reducing cancer-related fatigue. Most of the included studies had low risk of methodological quality problems; however, 59 studies had low methodological quality.Linking Evidence to Action: Different interventions have their own sets of advantages for addressing cancer-related fatigue. These results can be utilized as evidence-based interventions for healthcare workers and patients to manage cancer-related fatigue.

Blue-wavelength Light Therapy for Post-traumatic Brain Injury Sleepiness, Sleep Disturbance, Depression, Fatigue: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis

“…For example, a recent review suggested that bright light therapy was effective for seasonal and non-seasonal depression and depression in dementia [39]. In addition, another systematic review also found that bright light therapy combined with psychosocial therapies was ranked the best in reducing cancer-related fatigue [40]. Taken together, the present and previous ndings suggest that bright light therapy, especially the BWLT, is effective in mitigating depressive and fatigue symptoms across the medical and psychiatric conditions, including the sequelae of TBI.…”

The Effect of Familiarization on the Reliability of Isokinetic Assessment in Breast Cancer Survivors

“…Likewise, cancer-related fatigue is a subjective sense of exhaustion not relieved by rest that, also, reduces overall functionality and physical performance [12,24,36], which can play a significant role on exacerbating the loss of muscle tissue commonly observed in cancer survivors [4]. Physical exercise interventions, such as strength training, have been proposed to improve muscle function, attenuating cancer-related fatigue and cancer-induced muscle wasting [17,31,32,38]. However, to assess the effect of training interventions, it is important to use reliable measurements to meaningfully detect changes, if indeed these changes have been promoted by training and not by motor learning from repeating testing [19].…”

Fatigue and lethargy in palliative care

“…A more recent systematic review and meta-analysis showed that multimodal therapies, qigong, aerobic exercise and cognitive behavioural therapy were most useful in helping fatigue. However, none of the studies were of high quality (Wu et al., 2019).…”