Nonparametric Hemodynamic Deconvolution of fMRI Using Homomorphic Filtering

Abstract

Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) is an indirect measure of neural activity which is modeled as a convolution of the latent neuronal response and the hemodynamic response function (HRF). Since the sources of HRF variability can be nonneural in nature, the measured fMRI signal does not faithfully represent underlying neural activity. Therefore, it is advantageous to deconvolve the HRF from the fMRI signal. However, since both latent neural activity and the voxel-specific HRF is unknown, the deconvolution must be blind. Existing blind deconvolution approaches employ highly parameterized models, and it is unclear whether these models have an over fitting problem. In order to address these issues, we 1) present a nonparametric deconvolution method based on homomorphic filtering to obtain the latent neuronal response from the fMRI signal and, 2) compare our approach to the best performing existing parametric model based on the estimation of the biophysical hemodynamic model using the Cubature Kalman Filter/Smoother. We hypothesized that if the results from nonparametric deconvolution closely resembled that obtained from parametric deconvolution, then the problem of over fitting during estimation in highly parameterized deconvolution models of fMRI could possibly be over stated. Both simulations and experimental results demonstrate support for our hypothesis since the estimated latent neural response from both parametric and nonparametric methods were highly correlated in the visual cortex. Further, simulations showed that both methods were effective in recovering the simulated ground truth of the latent neural response.

State-Space Analysis of Granger-Geweke Causality Measures with Application to fMRI

“…Recent approaches include Khalidov, Fadili, Lazeyras, Ville, and Unser (2011), Zafer, Blu, and Ville (2014), Wu et al (2013), Sreenivasan, Havlicek, and Deshpande (2015) and our approach using Laguerre-polynomials (Cassidy, Long, Rae, & Solo, 2012). …”

Advice Taking from Humans and Machines: An fMRI and Effective Connectivity Study

“…Blind hemodynamic deconvolution of the mean ROI BOLD time series was performed using a Cubature Kalman filter, which has been shown to be extremely efficient for jointly estimating latent neural signals and the spatially variable HRFs (Havlicek et al, 2011). In addition, recent research has shown that this model is not susceptible to over-fitting and produces estimates that are comparable to non-parametric methods (Sreenivasan et al, 2015). Hemodynamic deconvolution removes the inter-subject and inter-regional variability of the HRF (Handwerker et al, 2004) as well as its smoothing effect and therefore, increases the effective temporal resolution of the signal.…”

Diffusion of responsibility attenuates altruistic punishment: A functional magnetic resonance imaging effective connectivity study

“…Blind hemodynamic deconvolution of BOLD signals was performed using a Cubature Kalman filter which has been shown to be extremely efficient for jointly estimating latent neural signals and spatially variable HRFs [Havlicek et al, ]. In addition, recent research has shown that this model is not susceptible to over‐fitting and produces estimates which are comparable to nonparametric methods [Sreenivasan et al, ]. Hemodynamic deconvolution removes the intersubject and inter‐regional variability of the HRF [Handwerker et al, ] as well as the smoothing effect of the HRF and, therefore, increases the effective temporal resolution of the signal.…”