“…The interpretation of secondary loops has, to date, been limited to the study of specific material examples, being related to physical microstructural features such as non-affine deformation (Jeyaseelan and Giacomin (2008)) and 3/13 the absence of long-chain branching in polymer melts (Stadler et al (2008)). However, such secondary loops have been observed for many different material systems including micellar solutions (Ewoldt et al (2008)), a polystyrene solution (Jeyaseelan and Giacomin (2008)), several molten polymers (Tee and Dealy (1975), Stadler et al (2008)), star-polymer networks (Rogers and Vlassopoulos (2009)), as well as Xanthan gum solutions and an invert-emulsion drilling fluid (see Ewoldt et al, Rheol Acta, accompanying manuscript). Nonlinear constitutive models can also show secondary loops, examples include a non-affine network model (Jeyaseelan and Giacomin (2008)), a tube-based model of entangled linear polymers (Leygue et al (2006); Stadler et al (2008)), and a single mode Giesekus model (demonstrated here).…”