‘No, you should not beat our child because he will become aggressive:’ Applying a multi-method approach to explore intergenerational transmission of parenting practices

Abstract

Background Exploring the cultural context of intergenerational continuity of warm and harsh parenting informs parents motivations to adopt specific parenting behaviours. Objective Parents’ perceptions of being parented in the past and their current parenting as well as adolescents’ perceptions of current parenting were explored applying a multi-method approach. Methods Following written informed consent, a total of 24 interviews with 10 families (dyads of 14 parents and ten adolescents) from Udupi taluk in southern India was conducted. In the first stage, in-depth interviews were conducted with parent participants (Generation 1 (G1)) and in the second stage, adolescents (Generation 2 (G2)) participated in the photovoice component. Multiple forms of data including photographs, journals and interviews facilitated using the SHOWeD model were collected and were analysed thematically using ATLAS.ti(v.8). Results Subtle changes in reinforcing culture-specific gender norms between generations were elicited. Differences in communication, granting autonomy to female adolescents, and in disciplining methods between G1 and G2 were observed. Warm parenting was transmitted between generations while harsh parenting in G1 in the presence of external social support was discarded in favor of warm parenting in G2. Conclusion We provide evidence for perceptions of parenting and adolescent behaviors across two generations. Transmission of warm parenting and interruption in the cycle of harsh parenting in the presence of external social support were significant findings. Related theoretical and methodological applications are discussed.

The dynamic nature of parenting practices: a qualitative enquiry of parenting adolescents during COVID-19

“…Similar results have been found in Eastern cultures as well, for instance, He et al (2020) , in their study on a sample of 192 participants from rural China found that the emotional warmth of one’s parents was significantly associated with caregiver’s warmth, whereas the rejective parenting style of one’s parents was consequently associated with the hostile parenting style of the caregiver toward their children. However, yet another study conducted in southern India with 10 families indicated that although warm parenting was transmitted across generations, the hostile parenting behavior was discontinued in the presence of external social support ( Sekaran et al, 2021 ). Nonetheless, even though some researchers have initiated investigations of intergenerational transmission of parenting (for ex., Honig, 2014 ; Uba and Jain, 2019 ), there exists relatively marginal literature regarding such transmissions.…”

Predictors of Adolescent Internalizing and Externalizing Mental Health Symptoms: A School-Based Study in Southern India

“…Research shows that up to half of all mental health conditions begin during adolescence, and this is a universal phenomenon [2,12,13]. Precursors to emotional and behavioral problems may include immediate influences including the family, parental warmth and control [14][15][16][17], and peer relationships [18,19]. Hostile parenting is considered a risk factor for emotional and behavioral problems, whereas consistent parenting is a protective factor [20].…”

The Association Between Religiosity and Social Behaviour Among Children: A Romanian Perspective

“…This hypothesis is sustained by the social learning theory, according to which observing others in their social context is important in moulding one's behaviour, attitudes and emotional reactions. The child's inclinations and moral cognition are established through social learning and is gradually constructed by observations, modelling and consolidation (Chandra Sekaran et al, 2021;Kristjansson, 2004). Thus, socialization can represent a process through which a child acquires standards, values and practices from the society in which he/she was raised, gradually coming to share different aspects of the emotions, cognition and behaviour of the members from that society (Bennett, 2005).…”