Summary• How the balance between exogenous and endogenous nitrogen for shoot growth varies with soil nitrogen availability, and its consequences on leaf life-span, have rarely been studied within a single species in the field.• In this study, we investigated two Rhododendron ferrugineum populations with contrasting leaf life-span. Soil nitrogen availability and nitrogen resorption of different leaf age classes were assessed, as were the interactions between plant compartments, using 15 N labelling and sink organ suppression.• The population growing on poorer soil had a shorter leaf life-span (17.9 vs 21.5 months) and a higher net contribution of leaf reserves to shoot growth (32% vs 15%), achieved by faster nitrogen resorption and greater shedding of young nitrogen-rich leaves. For both populations, wood contributed to over 40% of shoot nitrogen demand. Both the negative relationship between current-year shoot mass and the percentage of 1-yr-old attached leaves and the delay of leaf shedding after bud removal suggest that shoot development has a strong effect on leaf life-span.• Our results suggest that, contrary to the evolutionary response, plastic response to low soil nitrogen could reduce leaf life-span in evergreen plants. In addition, leaf life-span seems to be strongly influenced by the discrepancy between shoot nitrogen demand and soil nitrogen uptake rather than nitrogen demand alone.Abbreviations: ALx, attached/green leaves of the xth age cohort (0, 1, 2, 3 yr); DLx, dead/fallen leaves of the xth age cohort (0, 1, 2, 3 yr); LLS, leaf life-span (months); LMA, leaf mass area; MRT, mean residence time; N mass , nitrogen content [g (g DW −1 )]; NR, nitrogen resorption of ALx (g g −1 ); R EFF , nitrogen resorption efficiency (g g −1 ).