Nichtinvasive Diagnostik der chronisch stabilen koronaren Herzkrankheit: evidenzbasierte und nicht evidenzbasierte diagnostische Algorithmen

Abstract

In Germany, every second left heart catheterization has no immediate interventional or surgical consequence. One main reason for this limited quality of indication of many left heart catheterizations is presumably the inaccuracy of preinvasive testing that is mainly based on clinical evaluation and exercise ECG in Germany. However, exercise electrocardiography has several limitations. The central issues are the inability to exercise in many, especially elderly patients, and the missing interpretability of the stress ECG in cases with already pathological rest ECG. In 2006, the "Nationale Versorgungsleitlinie Chronische KHK (NVL KHK)" was published in Germany, adopting for the first time the evidence-based algorithms of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association (ACC/AHA) guidelines for non-invasive stress testing and complementary stress imaging. Stress imaging methods considered comparable and interchangeable are the following: stress echocardiography combined with physical or pharmacological stress testing, myocardial perfusion imaging with physical or pharmacological stress testing, dobutamine stress magnetic resonance imaging (DSMR), or myocardial perfusion magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Basically, no stress imaging method is definitely superior to the others, each method has its own advantages and disadvantages that should be considered and adjusted to the individual patient. Of pivotal importance of all stress imaging methods is the high negative predictive value of 99% of a normal study predicting a very low (< 1%) cumulative likelihood of cardiac death or myocardial infarction for at least the next 12 months. Hence, in most clinical circumstances, coronary angiography is not necessary during the 12 months subsequent to a normal stress imaging study. In contrast to these established and evidence-based recommendations of the "Nationale Versorgungsleitlinie Chronische KHK" mainly focusing on ischemia stress imaging, many diagnostic centers have developed their own non-evidence based algorithms. In these non-evidence based algorithms the morphology-oriented non-invasive CT coronary angiography has taken over the diagnostic part of evidence-based ischemia stress imaging. However, beyond the scientifically established prognostic value of calcium scoring, there is so far no scientific evidence showing that morphology-oriented CT coronary angiography protocols are superior to functional stress imaging. A new innovative approach of staged non-invasive diagnostics for patients with intermediate likelihood (10-90%) of coronary artery disease are the 2010 recommendations of the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) guiding the National Health Service (NHS) in the United Kingdom. Following this guidance, in patients with an estimated likelihood of CAD of 10-29% CT calcium scoring should be offered as first-line method, in patients with an estimated likelihood of CAD of 30-60% non-invasive functional imaging should be offered primarily, and in patients with an estimated like...