New Institutional Economics' contribution to strategic groups analysis

Abstract

Rather than consider the two broad strands of strategic group research-performance-based and behavior-based studies-as competing approaches, we argue that they relate to complementary levels of analysis. We present a four-level framework for analyzing structures within industries drawn from New Institutional Economics (NIE) which covers different approaches to strategic group formation from institutional isomorphism and embeddedness through to the firm-level effects of certain resource deployments. We apply an institutional approach to a case study of the Australian banking industry and supplement this with a quantitative approach based around key strategic variables. This analysis suggests that distinct groups have emerged due to the institutional environment and the different regulatory environments experienced by various banks in the industry. Copyright © 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Strategic groups and performance differences among academic medical centers

“…Strategic variables such as marketing methods and the use of certain technologies can create effective mobility barriers. These barriers protect each strategic group from outside competition and may lead to performance differences (Osborne, Stubbart, & Ramaprasad, 2001;Short, Ketchen, Palmer & Hult, 2007;Tywoniak, Galvin, & Davies, 2007). McGee (2003) differentiates between market-related barriers (e.g., advertising, sales-force size, and breadth of product line) and asset-related barriers (e.g., product patents).…”

Competitive Strategy, Uncertainty, and Performance: An Exploratory Assessment of China and Turkey

“…A renewed interest in organizational economics, encompassing issues such as incentives, agency theory, transactions cost theory, authority and delegation, decentralization, and property rights theory, has built upon both IO and the RBV (Fulghieri & Hodrick, 2006;Kim & Mahoney, 2005;Tywoniak, Galvin, & Davies, 2007).…”

“…Performance-based strategy research begins with the industry and works downward toward strategic groups. In comparison, behavior-based studies tend to start with organization-level data and work upward toward the strategic groups (Tywoniak et al, 2007). The behavioral approach includes the notion of strategic uncertainty, top management's ability to properly assess the firm's external environment.…”

What drives firm performance: environment or capabilities?

“…Indeed, any attempt to build on the merits of both I/O and RBV must account for the varying degrees of infl uence of both industry factors and fi rm resources on performance (Claver-Cortes et al, 2004;Roquebert et al, 1996;Spanos et al, 2004). A renewed interest in organizational economics emerged in the 2000s, including issues such as incentives, agency theory, transaction cost theory, authority and delegation, decentralization, and property rights theory, has built upon both I/O and the RBV (Fulghieri and Hodrick, 2006;Foss and Foss, 2005;Kim and Mahoney, 2005;Sheehan and Foss, 2007;Tywoniak et al, 2007;Whinston, 2003).…”