New directions in e-learning research in health professions education: Report of two symposia

Abstract

Background: The use of Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI) is rising across health professions education. Research to date is of limited use in guiding the implementation and selection of CAI innovations. Aims: In the context of two symposia, systemic reviews were discussed that evaluate literature in Internet-based learning, Virtual Patients, and animations. Each session included a debate with the goal of reaching consensus on best current practices and future research. Methods: Thematic analysis of the discussions was performed to arrange the questions by theme, eliminate redundancy, and craft them into a cohesive narrative. Results: The question analysis revealed that there are clear advantages to the use of CAI, and that established educational theories should certainly inform the future development and selection of CAI tools. Schools adopting CAI need to carefully consider the benefits, cost, available resources, and capacity for teachers and learners to accept change in their practice of education. Potential areas for future research should focus on the effectiveness of CAI instructional features, integration of e-learning into existing curricula and with other modalities like simulation, and the use of CAI in assessment of higher-level outcomes. Conclusions: There are numerous opportunities for future research and it will be important to achieve consensus on important themes.

Introducing e-learning/teaching in a physiology course for medical students: acceptance by students and subjective effect on learning

“…A study by Means and colleagues (17) found beneficial effects of e-learning, especially when blended with conventional teaching. In addition, Triola et al (23) emphasized the advantages of e-learning when the results of various studies were summarized. On the other hand, several studies have found e-learning not to be more effective than conventional learning methods (2,9,15,18,22), and the outcome of learning seems to depend more strongly on the time on task instead of the method (4).…”

An innovative blended learning approach using virtual patients as preparation for skills laboratory training: perceptions of students and tutors

“…To date VPs have mainly been reported as stand-alone teaching units. Several authors have suggested investigating how to successfully integrate e-learning in general, and VP in particular, into a curriculum [12-15]. …”

Global Application of the Assessment of Communication Skills of Paediatric Endocrinology Fellows in the Management of Differences in Sex Development Using the ESPE E-Learning.Org Portal

“…However, online learning can be very useful when preparing for face-to-face experiences. Ideally, educators will be best served by blending online learning and face-to-face instruction in individual or small group discussions [24-26]. In this context, e-learning can play an important role, not only for assessing medical knowledge, but also for assessing and learning communication skills [27] – of trainees, as well as physician educators.…”