In this first report on the chemistry of the sponge Stylissa caribica, two known bromopyrrole metabolites and a new compound, N-methyldibromoisophakellin (1), were isolated and identified. The structure of 1 was determined using spectroscopic methods and the computer program COCON. N-Methyldibromoisophakellin (1) was shown to be the only secondary metabolite in Stylissa caribica that, at its natural concentration, is active as a feeding deterrent against a common omnivorous reef fish.In a recent survey of the chemical antipredatory defenses of 71 species of Caribbean sponges, it was discovered that all of the five species within the family Axinellidae yielded crude organic extracts that deterred the feeding of predatory reef fish in aquarium assays. 1 More recently it has been shown that one species, Axinella corrugata (previously Teichaxinella morchella), yielded high concentrations of stevensine as the single compound responsible for feeding deterrency. 2 The purpose of the study reported herein was to isolate and identify the metabolite(s) responsible for the chemical defense of Stylissa caribica, a sponge closely related to A. corrugata. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report on the chemistry of S. caribica.A series of brominated pyrrole alkaloids have been isolated from a specimen of the sponge S. caribica collected off the coast of Sweetings Cay, Bahamas. Bioassay-guided fractionation of the methanol extract of this sponge resulted in the isolation of two known bromopyrrole-derived alkaloids, dibromoisophakellin (2, 13 mg) and ageliferin (3, 3 mg), as well as the new compound N-methyldibromoisophakellin (1, 140 mg). We describe herein the isolation, structural elucidation, and antifeedant properties against the common predatory reef fish Thalassoma bifasciatum of the new bromopyrrole alkaloid 1.The compounds 1-3 could be isolated using previously reported methods (details see Experimental Section and Supporting Information). The brominated alkaloids dibromoisophakellin (2) and ageliferin (3) Table 1). By comparison of δ C of 1 with all known intramolecular cyclized oroidin derivatives, the isophakellin skeleton was obtained. 4 Therefore, the structure of 1 was identified and confirmed by COCON 5 as the N-methyl derivative of dibromoisophakellin (2). The absolute configuration of 1 was determined by comparison of the optical rotation of 1 with that of 2. 3a Since recent studies 6 have found no evidence for structural or nutritional defenses, deterrent metabolites appear to be the principal defensive strategy of Caribbean sponges against predatory reef fishes. To investigate the feeding deterrency of the major metabolite of S. caribica, aquarium assays were performed using previously reported methods. 7 When incorporated into artificial foods at the same volumetric concentration as found in sponge tissue (0.9 mg/mL), N-methyldibromoisophakellin (1) deterred