Neuroimaging studies of cognitive remediation in schizophrenia: A systematic and critical review

Abstract

AIMTo examine the effects of cognitive remediation therapies on brain functioning through neuroimaging procedures in patients with schizophrenia.METHODSA systematic, computerised literature search was conducted in the PubMed/Medline and PsychInfo databases. The search was performed through February 2016 without any restrictions on language or publication date. The search was performed using the following search terms: [(“cogniti*” and “remediation” or “training” or “enhancement”) and (“fMRI” or “MRI” or “PET” or “SPECT”) and (schizophrenia or schiz*)]. The search was accompanied by a manual online search and a review of the references from each of the papers selected, and those papers fulfilling our inclusion criteria were also included.RESULTSA total of 101 studies were found, but only 18 of them fulfilled the inclusion criteria. These studies indicated that cognitive remediation improves brain activation in neuroimaging studies. The most commonly reported changes were those that involved the prefrontal and thalamic regions. Those findings are in agreement with the hypofrontality hypothesis, which proposes that frontal hypoactivation is the underlying mechanism of cognitive impairments in schizophrenia. Nonetheless, great heterogeneity among the studies was found. They presented different hypotheses, different results and different findings. The results of more recent studies interpreted cognitive recovery within broader frameworks, namely, as amelioration of the efficiency of different networks. Furthermore, advances in neuroimaging methodologies, such as the use of whole-brain analysis, tractography, graph analysis, and other sophisticated methodologies of data processing, might be conditioning the interpretation of results and generating new theoretical frameworks. Additionally, structural changes were described in both the grey and white matter, suggesting a neuroprotective effect of cognitive remediation. Cognitive, functional and structural improvements tended to be positively correlated.CONCLUSIONNeuroimaging studies of cognitive remediation in patients with schizophrenia suggest a positive effect on brain functioning in terms of the functional reorganisation of neural networks.

Cognitive enhancement interventions for people with bipolar disorder: A systematic review of methodological quality, treatment approaches, and outcomes

“…Neuroimaging evidence indicate aberrant frontal activation as an underlying factor for cognitive impairment in BD . Meta‐analyses in people with schizophrenia have associated CR interventions with enhanced frontal activations suggesting this might be a reliable biomarker of cognitive improvement . Only a few studies have examined potential changes in neural activation following CR in people with BD, with findings supporting the model of hypofrontality and that modulating activity in frontal areas, particularly in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, potentially underlies cognitive improvement .…”

Nonsocial and social cognition in schizophrenia: current evidence and future directions

“…Further, these gains were durable at follow‐up assessments following active treatment (d=0.43). Notably, beyond cognitive task improvement, there is emerging evidence that cognitive remediation is also associated with significant structural (both grey and white matter) and functional (particularly in prefrontal and thalamic regions) brain changes.…”

Computerised working memory‐based cognitive remediation therapy does not affect Reading the Mind in The Eyes test performance or neural activity during a Facial Emotion Recognition test in psychosis

“…Similarly, fMRI‐based studies further suggest that working memory‐based cognitive training impacts upon networks important for social cognition, including the default mode network, which plays a role in theory of mind (Penadés et al., ) and the affective network, which plays a role in emotion processing (Donohoe et al., ). Supporting these findings, fMRI studies of CT programmes in schizophrenia most commonly report increased neural activity after training within the prefrontal cortex, a brain region that shows reduced activity in schizophrenia and plays an important role in social cognition (Penadés et al., ). For example, individuals with prefrontal lesions perform more poorly on tests of mental state decoding from viewed facial expressions (Dal Monte et al., ).…”