Network analysis of symptoms in a Parkinson patient using experience sampling data: An n = 1 study

Abstract

Background Around 50% of Parkinson's disease patients experience motor fluctuations after long‐term treatment with levodopa. These fluctuations may be accompanied by mood fluctuations. Routine cross‐sectional assessments cannot capture the extent of these motor and mood fluctuations and their possible associations. Experience sampling techniques that use frequently repeated measurements of symptoms over time are able to capture such fluctuations. Based on such data, longitudinal associations between symptoms can be studied using network analysis. Aim The purpose of this study is to identify longitudinal associations between motor symptoms and mood states in a patient with Parkinson's disease. Methods A 53‐year‐old man with Parkinson's disease and motor fluctuations collected experience sampling data during 34 consecutive days. A set of dependent variables included tremor, rigidity, balance problems, and “on/off” state, and the mood variables anxiety, cheerful, and “down.” Independent variables were the same variables assessed at the preceding measurement. Regression coefficients were calculated and presented in a network graph. Results In this patient, anxiety and cheerfulness had a central position within the symptom network. Higher anxiety was prospectively associated with increased rigidity and tremor and with feeling “down.” Cheerfulness was associated with less tremor. Balance problems were not influenced by cheerfulness nor anxiety, but increased balance problems were associated with reduced cheerfulness at the next assessment. Feeling “down” did not influence self‐reported motor symptom severity at the next assessment. Conclusion This n = 1 study shows that network analysis of experience sampling data may reveal longitudinal associations of self‐reported motor symptoms and mood states that may have relevance for treatment strategies. © 2018 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society

Monitoring Parkinson’s disease symptoms during daily life: a feasibility study

“…This argument is supported by a previous N = 1 study, in which the completion rate was 47% in week 1 and dropped to 29% in week 2. 18 We did however not see any differences between average completion rates per day (Supplementary Fig. 1).…”

“…Although the combination of wearable sensors with ESM or other electronic diary methods was often suggested in PD, 18,19 and although this combination was used in other populations before, 20–25 it has never been tested in PD so far. Consequently, this project aims to prove the feasibility of the new monitoring system in PD patients during daily life for two consecutive weeks.…”

Mobile Health Daily Life Monitoring for Parkinson Disease: Development and Validation of Ecological Momentary Assessments

“…The scarce literature describing EMA in Parkinson disease reports feasibility in small cohorts of up to 5 patients. Reproduction and further investigation of the usefulness and value of EMA in Parkinson disease are needed [4,16,23].…”

Temporal Associations between Sleep and Daytime Functioning in Parkinson’s Disease: A Smartphone-Based Ecological Momentary Assessment

“…EMA is an intensive longitudinal method for collecting data, wherein individuals repeatedly report their experience over a brief period. A recent study used such an experiencesampling approach to examine the relation of motor symptoms and mood in a single individual with PD (van der Velden, Mulders, Drukker, Kuijf, & Leentjens, 2018). This method maximizes ecological validity by assessing individuals in their natural environments and minimizes recall bias by asking about experiences occurring in the current moment.…”