Nested Analysis as a Mixed-Method Strategy for Comparative Research

Abstract

D espite repeated calls for the use of "mixed methods" in comparative analysis, political scientists have few systematic guides for carrying out such work. This paper details a unified approach which joins intensive case-study analysis with statistical analysis. Not only are the advantages of each approach combined, but also there is a synergistic value to the nested research design: for example, statistical analyses can guide case selection for in-depth research, provide direction for more focused case studies and comparisons, and be used to provide additional tests of hypotheses generated from small-N research. Small-N analyses can be used to assess the plausibility of observed statistical relationships between variables, to generate theoretical insights from outlier and other cases, and to develop better measurement strategies. This integrated strategy improves the prospects of making valid causal inferences in cross-national and other forms of comparative research by drawing on the distinct strengths of two important approaches.

International Institutions and Domestic Politics: Can Preferential Trading Agreements Help Leaders Promote Economic Reform?

“…Our quantitative model below predicts an EU-South Africa PTA particlarly well, so the case is useful for illustrating our theory (Lieberman 2005;Seawright and Gerring 2008). It features a prominent leader change, namely Nelson Mandela's becoming the country's President, at the time of democratization as the black majority gained suffrage.…”

The problem of comparison in comparative regionalism

“…A promising line of enquiry is to use mixed methods (that is, to combine, within the same research project or programme, qualitative and quantitative approaches in order to generate synergies), like in Lieberman's proposal for 'nested analysis'. 59 However, it should be observed that the use of mixed methods necessitates the use of research projects of a minimum scale, possibly going beyond the average scale of individual (comparative) research endeavours.…”

Civilianizing Civil Conflict: Civilian Defense Militias and the Logic of Violence in Intrastate Conflict

“…To test our hypotheses we apply a nested mixed-method research design (Lieberman 2005). We first assess our arguments using statistical analysis.…”

“…For a deeper assessment of our causal argument we undertake a 'model testing' case analysis (Lieberman 2005). We focus on civilian defense forces in Anbar province, Iraq (2005Iraq ( -2009.…”