1Most of this debate concerned the neonatal outcome of the second born twin. The second twin is at a greater risk of hypoxia because complications such as malpresentation, the longer second stage, cord prolapse and abruptio placentae are more likely to occur at delivery of the second twin.2 This has prompted several countries and academic centres to examine their data on neonatal outcome and mode of delivery in twin gestations.
Evidence for routine elective caesarean sectionThe adverse effect of vaginal delivery on the second twin was first raised in a population-based study of more than one million term births in Sweden. 3 The Swedish Medical Birth Registry is one of the most complete birth registers in the world and it contains data on 98-99% of births in Sweden. Thorngren-Jerneck et al used data from the register for babies born between 1988-1997 to examine the obstetric risk factors for low 5 minute Apgar scores. In this study the greatest risk factors for an infant born with a 5-minute apgar score below 7 were vaginal breech delivery (OR 6.7), birth weights above 5kg (OR 6.3) and second born twins (OR 4.1).Smith et al subsequently retrospectively evaluated data from The Scottish Morbidity Record and perinatal death records from England, North Ireland and Wales to determine the risk of perinatal death among twins born at term in relation to mode of delivery. 4,5 The Scottish register is subject to regular quality assurance tests and has been more than 99% complete since the 1970s. Eight-thousand and seventy three twin pairs were examined in the Scottish study. The odds ratio for death after vaginal delivery of the second twin due to intrapartum anoxia was 21 (95% CI 3.4-868.5). This risk was