Neoliberal Awakenings: A Case Study of University Leaders’ Competitive Advantage Sensemaking

Abstract

Market principles in higher education seem to have generated a neoliberal awakening. A corollary of such market principles is the need for universities to develop effective strategies that give them competitive advantage. Thus, competitive advantage represents a key construct of neoliberalism, where the focus in this paper is on how university leaders, therefore, make sense of competitive advantage. Based on a comparative and instrumental case study using two close rival universities in England, three sensemaking dilemmas emerge as core elements of how university leaders conceptualize competitive advantage. The first one is about environmental fit or misfit. The second one is about seizing or missing opportunities.The third one is about finding a frame of reference. These dilemmas are valuable as they provide a possibility to understand what competitive advantage means in higher education, where the standard tenets of the concept, such as higher profits, might not always be helpful.

Just Let Us Be: Domination, the Postcolonial Condition, and the Global Field of Business Schools

“…We analysed the diary through thematic analysis, partly inspired by the Gioia method (see, Gioia, Corely & Hamilton (2013)), and its variations (see Abreu Pederzini (2016Pederzini ( , 2018aPederzini ( , 2018b). Here, similar to a grounded approach, first-order codes (usually in vivo codes) are developed.…”

Re-valuing higher education: learning(s) and teaching(s) in contested spaces

“…These include, but are not limited to, shifts in the focus of a university education to support the neoliberal agenda undertaken globally by governments across the last few decades. Within neoliberalism, market outcomes are favoured over considerations of social good (Giroux & Searles, 2006;Harvey, 2007;Olssen & Peters, 2005;Tight, 2019) with universities forced to compete with each other for funding and students who come to be considered 'consumers ' (Abreu Pederzini, 2018).…”

Managerial learning challenges in a complex world

“…Now the question is, how could managers make sense of the complexity around them? The answer possibly comes from cognition (Balogun and Johnson, 2004;Lieberman, 2007;Weible et al, 2012;Abreu Pederzini, 2017c). Managers are bombarded with information that they need to process.…”