Need and demand in psychiatric emergency service utilization: explaining topographic differences of a utilization sample in Mannheim

Abstract

Up to now all investigations about the topographic distribution of psychiatric utilization rates ignore whether or not the patients really require care (need for care) respectively express that need by themselves (demand for care). To analyze utilization rates of the psychiatric emergency service of the Central Institute of Mental Health in Mannheim (CIMH), variables differentiating between need and demand for emergency care were included. The investigation is based on contacts in the psychiatric emergency service between 1982 and 1993 and comprises 6463 patients with 14,628 contacts. To operationalize the concepts of need and demand the items "instance of consultation", "reasons for consultation", "inpatient admission" and "rated urgency" from the standardized record system of the psychiatric emergency service were used. The association between need, demand and ecological, socio-demographic and distance-related factors were analyzed. The results show that demand for psychiatric emergency care is an important factor for explaining topographic differences in service utilization. Demand correlates with ecological, socio-demographic and distance related factors; need only correlates with age. The amount of demand also varies with specific mental disorders.

The geography of mental health: an established field?

“…[110][111][112]), or by multi-disciplinary teams involving geographers or people with a geographical background [113][114][115], there is arguably something distinctive about what academic geographers have to offer, particularly in the most recent scholarship, arising from a theorized sensitivity to the entangled relations of mental health, society, space and environment [7,9,36,116]. Whereas there are 'geographical' contributions made by workers from other disciplinary backgrounds (e.g.…”

Factors Related to Perceived Needs of Primary Caregivers of Patients with Schizophrenia

“…13 As these instruments do not explore the perceived needs of primary caregivers, research findings using these instruments cannot reflect the support modalities or the potential of caregivers to care for patients. A few studies [14][15][16][17] have detected factors related to needs status (i.e. needs met or unmet) but provided no insight into the target characteristics of subjects for allocating more resources.…”

The Peregrinating Psychiatric Patient in the Emergency Department

“…The most relevant articles included case series (two articles),7,8 case reports (three articles),9–11 and a review of pertinent pathology (one article) 3. Four papers compared traveling ED patients to non-traveling controls 5,12–14. Another 12 papers addressed psychiatric sequelae of acute travel, including seven articles on jet lag.…”

“…In studies that have compared travelers to non-travelers, patients appear more likely to have depressive, manic, or psychotic episodes 12,16. Patients coming to the ED from farther away within a metropolitan area may be relatively more likely to have severe mental illness and involuntary presentations 13,14…”