Near-shoring versus far-shoring: effects on customer perceived quality and purchase intention

Abstract

PurposeDriven by the disruptive effects of the Covid-19 pandemic, the ongoing debate about the international location of firms' manufacturing activities has increasingly highlighted the specific benefits and costs of near-shoring versus far-shoring. However, the effects of near-shoring versus far-shoring on customer perceived quality and purchase intention have not been examined. Thus, this study aims to develop a conceptual model and provide new evidence to fill this gap. In particular, the study explores the roles of brand familiarity and corporate social responsibility (CSR) to explain the different levels of perceived quality and purchase intention in relation to near-shoring versus far-shoring.Design/methodology/approachThis study includes two analyses of data collected from a sample of Italian customers. The first analysis consists of a 2 (high/low brand familiarity) × 3 (domestic insourcing, near-shoring, far-shoring) factorial design, and data are assessed via analyses of variance (ANOVA). The second analysis evaluates the suggested model in the two scenarios (near-shoring and far-shoring) via partial least squares–structural equation modelling (PLS-SEM) multigroup analysis.FindingsResults showed that customer perceived quality and purchase intention were significantly higher for near-shoring than for far-shoring, but only when brand familiarity was low. No significant difference was found for participants with a high level of brand familiarity. In addition, the level of a brand's pre-offshoring perceived CSR was negatively related to perceived quality, and this was conceptually justified by the CSR-washing effect. Again, this effect was found only when brand familiarity was low.Research limitations/implicationsThe findings contribute to advancing the current understanding of the multiple effects of the offshoring decision and clarify that near-shoring and far-shoring have different effects for customers with low brand familiarity. The findings also emphasise that the far-shoring decision can elicit the perception of decoupling between the firm's CSR claims and CSR actions, thus decreasing perceived quality.Practical implicationsThis study provides managers with additional inputs to make more informed decisions regarding offshoring. While the post-pandemic scenario seems to favour near-reshoring over far-shoring due to agility considerations, this study also provides additional evidence of the superiority of near-reshoring from the customer's perspective.Originality/valueThis is the first study to examine and prove the differential effects of near-shoring versus far-shoring on the customer's perceptions and behaviours.

Passengers' service perceptions emerging from user-generated content during the pandemic: the case of leading low-cost carriers

“…Consequently, many individuals were forced to delay holidays in the following months (Nilashi et al, 2021). The pandemic of COVID-19 has profoundly affected world healthcare and the economy (Colamatteo et al, 2021;Esposito et al, 2022;Jafari et al, 2021;Karatepe et al, 2022;Rezapouraghdam and Karatepe, 2020). In addition, the calamity of COVID-19 has altered travelers' behavior considerably, primarily due to confinement-related issues (Jafari et al, 2020).…”

“…, 2021). The pandemic of COVID-19 has profoundly affected world healthcare and the economy (Colamatteo et al. , 2021; Esposito et al.…”

Home or away?

“…Scope for these varying effects are evident in a study by Colamatteo et al (2021) into consumer perceptions of a leading Italian clothing and footwear brand. An online questionnaire measured brand familiarity levels, attitude towards the brand and perceptions of its CSR by survey participants.…”

Conceptual review of global outsourcing-offshoring in the last 20 years: Notes on systematic literature review

“…For companies, outsourcing-offshoring is considered a unique competitive strategic phenomenon in domestic and international markets. A review of several research articles regarding global outsourcing-offshoring shows that there are contradictions and differences between one study and another, we simply summarize that outsourcing can produce positive, unprofitable, varied, and moderate or even insignificant impacts on the company (Colamatteo et al, 2021;Handley & Benton, 2013;Pereira et al, 2019). Several positive research results show that global outsourcing-offshoring can have a good impact on cost savings, increased management effectiveness and flexibility, market access, and better quality of products and services (Colamatteo et al, 2021;Contractor et al, 2011;Roy & Sivakumar, 2011).…”