Navigating Diagnoses: Understanding Mind–Body Relations, Mental Health, and Stigma in Nepal

Abstract

Anthropologists and psychiatrists traditionally have used the salience of a mind–body dichotomy to distinguish Western from non-Western ethnopsychologies. However, despite claims of mind–body holism in non-Western cultures, mind–body divisions are prominent in non-Western groups. In this article, we discuss three issues: the ethnopsychology of mind–body dichotomies in Nepal, the relationship between mind–body dichotomies and the hierarchy of resort in a medical pluralistic context, and, lastly, the role of mind–body dichotomies in public health interventions (biomedical and psychosocial) aimed toward decreasing the stigmatization of mental illness. We assert that, by understanding mind–body relations in non-Western settings, their implications, and ways in which to reconstitute these relations in a less stigmatizing manner, medical anthropologists and mental health workers can contribute to the reduction of stigma in global mental healthcare.

Political violence and mental health: A multi-disciplinary review of the literature on Nepal

“…Without longitudinal research, however, a causal relation between political violence and psychological distress and mental disorders cannot be confirmed. Such longitudinal research would need to take into account local conceptualizations of mind and body (Kohrt & Harper, 2008), and local concepts and idioms of distress. These can be identified through qualitative research methods, e.g.…”

Understanding women’s experiences of distress during pregnancy in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania

“…However, PAW's initial reticence to discuss "psychological health" problems, may suggest informants did make mind-body illness distinctions. Kohrt & Harper (2008) explored the ethnopsychology of mind-body dichotomies in Nepal and showed, rather than a lack of mind-body division, emphasis on bodily presentations of psychological distress reflects presence of such divisions and the stigma associated with mental illness. These analyses did not allow exploration of influences of stigma on expressions of distress, however, negative attitudes towards mental disorders in Tanzanian communities have been reported (Whyte, 1991), as well as high felt and enacted stigma scores in facility-based ambulatory patients with mental disorder (Philip, 2003).…”

Four principles of mental health research and psychosocial intervention for child soldiers: lessons learned in Nepal

“…Mental health continues to carry a strong stigma in Nepal, as in most parts of the world (Kohrt & Harper, 2008). Mental health enquiries may appear to be accus ations that one is 'crazy' or 'mad', as was the case with terms used to describe post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) by some clinicians in Nepal.…”