Nature-based coastal restoration: Development of an early-rearing production protocol of sugar kelp (Saccharina latissima Linnaeus) for bottom planting activities in the Gulf of St-Lawrence (Québec, Canada)

Abstract

Successful bottom planting of indigenous macroalgae Saccharina latissima aimed at coastal restoration purposes require the mass production in controlled conditions of strongly fixed, healthy sporophytes followed by optimal transfer techniques in order to ensure viability and vigor of the young seedlings about to be directly introduced in the coastal environment. Early development of S. latissima submitted to different combinations of substrate type (natural vs artificial brick-shaped substrate), gametophyte spraying method (water-based vs binder-based) and water velocity (0.1 vs 0.2 m s-1) was evaluated during a growth trial that lasted 42 days. Overall, all experimental groups (8 in triplicate) reached the targeted length of 15 mm between 35-42 days post-seeding. No strong indications that the proposed 2×2×2 factorial design generated long lasting effects on growth and development indicators were observed (thallus length, SGR and % coverage). The observation of no persistent difference in the growth response of S. latissima under all experimental conditions, demonstrates that it is well suited for mass production of seedlings. Our results and evidenced-based practices led us to conclude that the use of an artificial substrate in combination with a binder-based gametophyte pulverization and the application of a velocity 0.2 m s-1 during early-growth could be adopted in a standardized protocol. We argue that 1) artificial substrates (uniform shape, stackable and rough surface) will most likely allow better use of a vessel’s open deck space and adherence of the developing holdfast; 2) the use of a binder may slow down the dehydration of the propagules and promote adhesiveness to the substrate during rearing, handling and transfer operations and under varying flow rates or wave actions respectively and 3) highest velocity should promote the selection of propagules with strongest attachment and thus possibly limit post-transfer dislodgement. We suggest further studies should 1) focus on identifying optimal gametophyte concentration at the spraying step, in order to reduce production costs and maximise productivity of seedling operations and 2) include biomass determination (g of tissue per cm2) in combination to the semi-quantitative density evaluation (% coverage) based on image-analysis, in order to improve our global assessment of growth.

The sugar kelp Saccharina latissima I: Recent advances in a changing climate

“…One strategy to recover populations is to plant new individuals where it has been lost/decreased, aiming to restore the populations. A few studies aiming to find the best techniques for restoration have been performed on S. latissima (Fredriksen et al 2020;Tsiamis et al 2020;Le François et al 2023). In a trial in Quebec, Canada, the production of S. latissima sporophytes was successful and worked best on artificial substrate and using a binder-based method for spraying gametophytes (Le François et al 2023).…”

“…A few studies aiming to find the best techniques for restoration have been performed on S. latissima (Fredriksen et al 2020;Tsiamis et al 2020;Le François et al 2023). In a trial in Quebec, Canada, the production of S. latissima sporophytes was successful and worked best on artificial substrate and using a binder-based method for spraying gametophytes (Le François et al 2023). In contrast, a study in Scotland revealed that the abundance of S. latissima and other kelps in an artificial reef was low, and in turn, turf seaweeds were abundant (Tsiamis et al 2020).…”