Natural disaster and political trust: A natural experiment study of the impact of the Wenchuan earthquake

Abstract

How do natural disasters impact political trust in contemporary China and what is the causal mechanism? Existing literature indicates that the severity of disaster, government relief effort and information dissemination are three key factors influencing people’s political trust in the context of acute natural disasters. This study uses the Wenchuan earthquake as a natural experiment and focuses specifically on the survey data collected right before and after the earthquake. It finds that primarily due to the ‘rally round the flag’ effect and extensive media coverage, public trust in government officials at all levels rose significantly after the earthquake. During the crisis, state-run media played a vital intermediate role. The more a citizen was exposed to the official media coverage, the more likely his/her political trust was to increase. However, the division of work in disaster relief among different levels of government resulted in differences in the level of increase in trust. As local-level governments are often directly responsible for the rescue and post-earthquake relief, they gained the highest increase in political trust, while state-level officials gained the least. The short-run upsurge in political trust receded as time went by. Government mobilization and media coverage are core contributing factors to the increase in political trust during the post-disaster period. Nevertheless, the key to consolidating political legitimacy lies in long-term efforts to build good and effective governance.

The Coronavirus Pandemic and Voter Turnout: Addressing the Impact of Covid-19 on Electoral Participation

“…It took place on March 11 th , just three days before a general election, killing 196 persons and wounding more than 2,000. 6 For a detailed analysis of the effect of natural disasters on institutional trust, seeYou et al (2020),Omelicheva (2011) orAbney and Hill (1966). To assess the effect of acts of terrorism on vote choice (especially government support), seeKibris (2011).…”

COVID-19 increased censorship circumvention and access to sensitive topics in China

“…Natural disasters, including epidemics, tend to alter trust in government officials. When a policy response is perceived as efficacious, support for the level of government perceived to have directed the response increases ( 12 , 53 ). On the other hand, neglectful responses can induce subsequent protest participation ( 11 ).…”

Pemanfaatan Data Twitter Dalam Penanggulangan Bencana Banjir dan Longsor

“…Belum lagi ditambah dengan narasi yang disebarkan oleh buzzer baik dalam bentuk akun asli, anonim maupun akun bot yang lebih bernuansa politik sehingga mengurangi nilai informasi kebencaannya. Narasi tersebut bisa berbentuk pujian yang berlebihan maupun ujaran kebencian terhadap kinerja suatu pemerintahan dalam penanggulangan bencana, hal ini dikarenakan kinerja pemerintahan dalam manajemen bencana dapat mempengaruhi kepercayaan publik [41].…”