Nationalism studies between methodological nationalism and orientalism: an alternative approach illustrated with the case ofElGreco inToledo,Spain

Abstract

Methodological nationalism is still dominant in nationalism studies. When studying the construction of national identities, scholars generally limit their study to the borders of one nation‐state, while only paying attention to members of that particular nation. Implicitly, foreign actors and influences are left out of the picture. I will challenge this methodological nationalism with a case study, which demonstrates that the place of Toledo within the Spanish national imagination, and more particularly that of El Greco, the most important representative of the city's artistic heritage, was largely determined by foreigners. During the nineteenth century, El Greco was rediscovered primarily by foreign scholars and artists. Moreover, it would be the rise of international tourism in the early twentieth century that convinced Toledans to adopt El Greco as the city's main artistic icon. This case, thus, clearly shows that in nationalism studies methodological nationalism can be avoided by also including foreign actors.

Nacionalismo, patriotismo e essencialismo na construção da identidade nacional brasileira

“…O fato da amostra ter sido composta por estudantes universitários também se apresenta como um limite deste estudo e aponta para outras possibilidades, com diferentes participantes, o que possibilita testar, em diferentes contextos, este modelo. O modelo proposto não pretende abarcar toda a complexidade da identidade nacional (Sim & Leith, 2014;Sperling, 2013, Storm, 2015Zwet, 2015), mas tem como principal objetivo tentar compreender como as variáveis, neste caso o patriotismo, o nacionalismo e o essencialismo, se confi guram para explicar esta identidade.…”

Nationalism, Patriotism, and Essentialism in the Construction of Brazilian National Identity

“…The fact that the sample was composed of university students also represents a limitation of this study and points to other possibilities, with different participants, which make it possible to test this model in different contexts. The proposed model is not intended to encompass all the complexity of national identity (Sim & Leith, 2014, Sperling, 2013, Storm, 2015Zwet, 2015). Rather, its main objective is to understand how the variables, in this case patriotism, nationalism, and essentialism, are confi gured to explain this identity.…”

The spatial turn and the history of nationalism: Nationalism between regionalism and transnational approaches

“…And during the nineteenth and twentieth century foreign travellers and tourists also played a crucial role in integrating the monuments of Al-Andalus, flamenco music and the figure of Don Juan -each of which initially was seen with suspicion by most domestic elitesinto the Spanish national imagination. 51…”