National spatial data infrastructure (nsdi) of Ukraine: what are its actual, feasible and simultaneously "correct" models?

Chabaniuk, V.; Dyshlyk, O.

doi:10.31548/zemleustriy2021.03.11

Cited by 3 publications

(17 citation statements)

References 8 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…The Spatial Information Infrastructure (SII) in this article is defined through the Spatial Information Infrastructure (SII) of Poland. The latter is described in the Polish Law "On SII" [8] and implemented, between others, in the form of the Polish SII Portal, which is briefly described in the article [5]. If we replace Poland with Ukraine, we will get our proposed representation of the future SII of Ukraine or the National SII (NSII).…”

Section: System Approach and General Scheme Of Researchmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…If we replace Poland with Ukraine, we will get our proposed representation of the future SII of Ukraine or the National SII (NSII). At the same time, the NSII should correspond to the Productprocess model of the development of the NSDI, which is described in the work [9].…”

Section: System Approach and General Scheme Of Researchmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Our Product-Process Model of NSDI development [9], uses the dualism "productprocess" at least, twice. In a potential NSDI, together with the product(s), the process(es) should be considered immediately.…”

Section: System Approach and General Scheme Of Researchmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…In the article [2], we considered examples of such processes -pilot services of NSDI in the eras of Web 1.0 and Web 1.0+. As a guideline for the processes of using NSDI in the work [5], we considered the processes of using the Geoportal of Poland.…”

Section: System Approach and General Scheme Of Researchmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…In the article [5], we introduced the term "harmonization with INSPIRE" in the title. We interpreted the harmonization with INSPIRE as the harmonization of Ukrainian spatial data, processes and the Law "On the National Geospatial Data Infrastructure", which were discussed in one way or another in that that article.…”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

See 4 more Smart Citations

Harmonization strategy of the spatial information infrastructure of Ukraine with INSPIRE. system approach

Chabaniuk,

Dyshlyk

2024

ZKMZ

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Van Gigch's system approach was applied to consider the option of systemic harmonization of the National Spatial Information Infrastructure of Ukraine (NSII) with INSPIRE. The article focuses on its most important part - the strategy of harmonization or, more specifically, strategic harmonization. The proposed strategic harmonization is suitable for practical implementation. For this purpose, NSII is understood as an extension of National Spatial Data Infrastructure (NSDI), and NSII and INSPIRE are represented by general systems (GS), whose practical feasibility is achieved by exemplification/interpretation by spatial information systems (SpIS) and certain their extensions - SpISb. The main attention is paid to the relation between the NSII and INSPIRE, with an emphasis on the harmonization relation. Possible alternatives to the problems or their solutions are not considered. In particular, the likely recent shift of interest from NSDI/NSII/INSPIRE to IGIF (Integrated Geospatial Information Framework) is not considered. This is possible because van Gigch's system approach used allows scaling, in this case - upwards, with the addition of higher levels of the hierarchy such as IGIF to the consideration. It is shown that, in the context of harmonization with INSPIRE, it is necessary to examine the harmonization of GS on at least three epistemological levels. GS corresponding to these levels can be called: strategic, tactical and operational. The GS for harmonization with INSPIRE can be represented by an integrated hierarchy or a unification of three GS components of these three levels. In the case of unification, each component of the collective agreement can be considered separately, but the context of harmonization must be mandatory. In particular, in strategic harmonization, it is mandatory to define its hierarchical relations with the "corresponding" tactical harmonization. Two main results were obtained in the article: 1) scientific - the structure of the phenomenon "harmonization of Ukrainian SII with INSPIRE" was defined, 2) practical - it was proved that the specified phenomenon is adequately represented by the GS and the corresponding SpISb.

show abstract

Section: System Approach and General Scheme Of Researchmentioning

confidence: 99%

Section: System Approach and General Scheme Of Researchmentioning

confidence: 99%

Section: System Approach and General Scheme Of Researchmentioning

confidence: 99%

Section: System Approach and General Scheme Of Researchmentioning

confidence: 99%

mentioning

confidence: 99%

See 3 more Smart Citations

Harmonization strategy of the spatial information infrastructure of Ukraine with INSPIRE. system approach

Chabaniuk,

Dyshlyk

2024

ZKMZ

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

Main conceptual provisions of the creation of an electronic state register of immovable cultural heritage of Ukraine. Part 1

Chabaniuk¹,

Dyshlyk²,

Polyvach³

et al. 2022

ZKMZ

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

To organize the creation of a new modern electronic State Register of Immovable Cultural Heritage (CH) of Ukraine, it is proposed to use a methodology based on the so-called Solutions Frameworks (SoFr) "something" = X, where X denotes both the specified system (subsystem) and class of such systems (subsystems). The application of SoFr to X entirely is called the main conceptual position 0 in the article, but despite its obviousness, the epigraph is applicable to the construction of X SoFr: “The hardest thing is to see what is right in front of you. - Goethe» [1; Preface]. X in the X SoFr record takes the meaning of a hierarchically structured Atlas Geoinformation System (AGIS), consisting of four strata (bottom-up ): Operational (w), Application (a), Conceptual (b) and General (g). X SoFr in the article takes three meanings: SoFr AGIS1 (defines the activity of creating the first stage of AGIS - AGIS1 = X), aSoFr AGIS1 (defines the activity "between" subsystems AGIS1 Application and Operational strata top-down ¯), bSoFr AGIS1 determines the activity "between" the subsystems of AGIS1 Conceptual and Application strata from top to bottom ¯). X SoFr is determined by the packages and the relation between them, the so-called "petrad" of Publication-Products-Processes-Basics-Services. Packages Products-Processes-Basics and the relation between them are called the main triad of SoFr. This triad is the basis of the main conceptual provisions 1-3. They are formulated as follows: SoFr.Products - provision 1, SoFr.Processes - provision 2, SoFr.Basics - provision 3. Part 1 describes the introduction to the problem and provisions 0 and 1. Provisions 2, 3 are described in Part 2. The methodology, based on the Solutions Frameworks, implements a specific systematic approach to creating a new modern electronic State Register of Immovable Cultural Heritage of Ukraine.

show abstract

CIDOC CRM as the basis of the Electronic State Register of Immovable Cultural Heritage of Ukraine

Chabaniuk,

Dyshlyk,

Pioro

2023

ZKMZ

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Abstract. The article is the final in a series of articles on Conceptual Provisions for the Creation of a New Electronic State Register of Immovable Cultural Heritage (CH) of Ukraine. These provisions correspond to the components of the Solutions Framework (SoFr) of special Spatial Information Systems (SpIS) defined in the monograph [15]. The special SpIS of the new registry of the CH of Ukraine should belong to the class of Atlas Geoinformation Systems (AGIS), which is described in [14]. The first queue of AGIS – AGIS-CH1 – is proposed as the first queue of the new electronic State Register of Immovable CH of Ukraine. The first queue should include, at least, three components that are simultaneously SoFr packages: Products-Processes-Basics. The conceptual provisions of AGIS-CH1 describe these three most important components of the architectural pattern of AGIS-CH1: AGIS-CH1.Products, Part 1 [17]; AGIS-CH1.Processes, Part 2 [18], AGIS-CH1.Basics, Part 3, consisting of two subparts, 3.1 and 3.2. Subpart 3.1 is described in the article [19]. This article describes subpart 3.2, which is called "Basics. CIDOC CRM". It consists of two main sections. The first of these initially examines the prerequisites that lead to the use of CIDOC CRM. Such prerequisites are two evolutions: system and subject. System evolution claims that the time has come to consider the registry of the CH of Ukraine as a SpIS of the Web 3.0 Formation, also known as the Semantic Web, especially if we have in mind the creation of a new registry. Subject evolution refers to the evolution of understanding of the domain of cultural heritage. From the review of this issue in the monograph [4], it is obvious that modern CH registers should be "process" rather than "product". In order to proceed to the consideration of CIDOC CRM with a better understanding of the essence of the issue, the CHARM model (Cultural Heritage Abstract Reference Model) was considered. CIDOC CRM can also be considered as such, but CHARM is described in an excellent monograph [4] that is practically applicable, unlike the scattered articles on CIDOC CRM. The second of the two main sections of the article deals with CIDOC CRM and its use. We do not describe CIDOC CRM completely. Attention is paid only to its "spatial" and "process" parts. In addition, attention is paid to the use of CIDOC CRM. For this, the information from the website (https://www.cidoc-crm.org/how-i-can-use-cidoc-crm, 2023-jun-26) is used first. Then there is some initial information about the Arches software platform. We offer the Arches platform for the implementation of AGIS-CH1.

show abstract

National spatial data infrastructure (nsdi) of Ukraine: what are its actual, feasible and simultaneously "correct" models?

Cited by 3 publications

References 8 publications

Harmonization strategy of the spatial information infrastructure of Ukraine with INSPIRE. system approach

Harmonization strategy of the spatial information infrastructure of Ukraine with INSPIRE. system approach

Main conceptual provisions of the creation of an electronic state register of immovable cultural heritage of Ukraine. Part 1

CIDOC CRM as the basis of the Electronic State Register of Immovable Cultural Heritage of Ukraine

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About