National culture and public-sector budgeting: the mediating role of country-level institutions using a structural equation modeling approach

Abstract

PurposeDespite cultural dimensions being included in hundreds of business and management research studies, there have been relatively few studies in public-sector accounting that include the use of cultural dimensions. It is posited that national cultural variables impact the institutions, which, in turn, have an influence on public-sector budgeting. The study aims to contribute to the literature by examining these relations in 31 countries.Design/methodology/approachThese relationships are empirically evaluated by structural equation modeling using measures of national culture from Global Leadership and Organizational Behavior Effectiveness (GLOBE) study and Worldwide Governance Indicators (WGIs) measures named institutions from the World Bank. Furthermore, measures of public-sector budgeting are evaluated in which public-sector budgeting is classified according to the legislative power of the purse and budget transparency.FindingsGenerally, findings reveal that institutions mediate the relationship among national cultural variables and budgeting at the national level. By that means, budgeting in a given nation is linked to the nation's supporting institutions which, in turn, are influenced by the national culture of those who maintain them. Particularly, power distance and uncertainty avoidance impact budgeting through the full mediation of institutions.Research limitations/implicationsThe World Bank's database used for the institutions contained over 200 countries (Kaufmann et al., 2007); the GLOBE cultural database (House et al., 2004) contained data for 62 societies; the public-sector budgeting (Qi and Mensah, 2011) included power of the purse and budgeting transparency country scores for 49 countries and the datasets comprised 31 nations, mostly from Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries. While smaller than we would have preferred, the size is consistent with other international studies (for instance: Waldman et al., 2006; Kwok and Tadesse, 2006).Practical implicationsThe findings of the paper suggest that any plan to improve a nation's budgeting should consider the links between budgeting, supporting institutions and the culture of those that run them. The formal adoption of new methods and standards by supporting institutions may not be enough without accompanying efforts to transform national culture.Originality/valueThe theoretical contribution of the paper is discussed further in the paper.

Culture, language, and accounting reform: a new perspective on IPSAS implementation

“…Firstly, it adds to prior studies on public sector accounting reforms in developing countries, such as by Ismail et al (2018), Tallaki and Bracci (2019) and Abdulkarim et al (2020). It also adds to the reform in public sector literature by responding to calls by Zarei et al (2022), who stressed the lack of cultural dimensions in prior IPSAS research, and Bergmann et al (2019), who pointed to theoretical perspectives that need to be expanded upon. Secondly, in addition to theoretical IPSAS culture studies, we contribute empirically as “[d]irect data from questionnaires is also less easy to acquire in developing countries” (Baydoun and Willet, 1995, p. 89).…”

“…This article explores the role of culture and language in the implementation of IPSAS in Qatar, building on the Hofstede–Gray model. Our study is motivated by the need to advance the existing literature on cultural aspects of public sector reform, which is especially limited in developing nations (de Silva Lokuwaduge and de Silva, 2020; Zarei et al , 2022).…”

“…While culture has been studied from different perspectives in the private sector using the Hofstede–Gray model, few studies have addressed the cultural dimension in public-sector accounting (Zarei et al , 2022). Public sector research has examined national culture (Hyndman and Connolly, 2011; Tallaki and Bracci, 2019) and accounting culture (Oulasvirta, 2014).…”

Post-Shock Budgeting: A Methodological Framework

“…Budgeting plays a pivotal role in the financial management of public and private organizations, serving as a crucial tool for planning, controlling, and evaluating performance (Zarei et al, 2022;Merchant and Van der Stede, 2017). Whereas being an important control system for most organisations (Hansen, 2011), dysfunctional consequences of budgetary controls have been documented and consequent dissatisfaction have motivated change in budgeting methods and practices (Alkaraan, 2020;Libby and Lindsay, 2010).…”

Innovative Reform Strategies of Artistic Practice of College Ethnic Music Education Based on Information Fusion Technology

“…Folk music is the artistic treasure and symbol of Chinese culture, and it is the spokesman and inheritance of Chinese culture, which has a wide range of themes and rich contents and contains very strong national culture and regional characteristics [1]- [4]. At present, cultural globalization is deepening, and from the reality of music teaching in Chinese universities, it must be closely combined with national culture for better development [5]- [6].…”