Narcissistic Force Meets Systemic Resistance: The Energy Clash Model

Abstract

This article focuses on the interplay between narcissistic leaders and organizations. It attempts to capture the gist of this interplay with a model outlining the narcissistic organizational trajectory. The Energy Clash Model borrows and adapts a phase/state physics metaphor to conceptualize narcissism as a force that enters or emerges in a stable system (i.e., organization) as a leader, destabilizes it, and stabilizes it at a different state or is expelled.The model consists of three time-contingent phases: perturbation, conflict, resolution. Narcissists create instability through waves of excitement, proposed reforms, and an inspiring vision for organization's future (perturbation). With the passage of time, though, systemic awareness and alertness intensify, as organizational costs-in terms of human resources and monetary losses-accrue. Narcissistic energy clashes directly with the organization (conflict), a clash likely to restabilize the system eventually. The conflict may provoke the exit of the narcissistic leader or his/her accommodation, that is, steps or controls negotiated between the system and the leader (resolution). Although narcissism is subject to organizational liability, narcissistic energy, when managed and directed properly, may contribute to organizational innovation and evolution. Thus, several interventions for working with narcissistic leaders are discussed.

Will they stay or will they go? Narcissistic admiration and rivalry predict ingroup affiliation and devaluation

“…Narcissists can exert substantial influence in social groups (see Sedikides & Campbell, 2017). The extent to which individual group members identify with and are loyal to groups, moreover, can have significant consequences for groups (Dess & Shaw, 2001).…”

I am the chosen one: Narcissism in the backdrop of self‐determination theory

“…They view themselves as special, unique, and great—what Ernest Jones () labeled “the God Complex”—while fantasizing about power, status, and social recognition (Zeigler‐Hill et al, ). Finally, they are argumentative and antagonistic (Sedikides & Campbell, ).…”

“…Moreover, when they receive negative feedback, they blame others (Campbell, Reeder, Sedikides, & Elliot, ) or disengage from its consequences (Thomaes & Sedikides, ). Overall, then, narcissists are no more effective or competent than non‐narcissists in the agentic domain (Sedikides & Campbell, ), although this conclusion needs to be qualified; narcissists perform relatively well when they believe that winning a competition will reap them the benefits of acclaim (Wallace & Baumeister, ).…”

“…The final reason for our focus on this trait is that narcissism has been seemingly rising in many professional settings (Sedikides & Campbell, ). It is seen as a leader’s trait, and so the pipeline to modern organizations involves the encouragement and cultivation of it.…”

Do consumer choices augment narcissism? The role of self-referent processing

“…For example, the prominence of CEO's photographs in companies' annual reports is positively associated with CEO's narcissism levels (Chatterjee & Hambrick, 2007;Sedikides & Campbell, 2017). Also, some studies have reported a positive relation between first-pronoun use and narcissism (Chatterjee & Hambrick, 2007;Fast & Funder, 2010;Raskin & Shaw, 1988; but see Carey et al, 2015).…”