Naming, Shaming and Fire Alarms: The Compilation, Development and Use of the List of World Heritage in Danger

Abstract

This article provides a comprehensive empirical analysis of the composition, development and use of the List of World Heritage in Danger (IDL) under the 1972 Convention concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage. The statutory records of this Convention have been coded in order to generate an overview of the development and use of the IDL between 1978 and 2017. The quantitative data was further developed by reference to World Heritage and transnational law literature. A key finding of this article is that the IDL serves a dual purpose in regulation: firstly, as a ‘fire alarm’ to alert the international community of imminent dangers at World Heritage sites; secondly, as a non-compliance procedure used for ‘naming and shaming’ states that breach the rules. The findings in this article have relevance for heritage scholars and policy makers concerned with the governance of World Heritage as well as those with a broader interest in non-compliance procedures under transnational environmental law.

Unesco World Heritage In The Face Of Global Challenges And Threats

“…Among these objects there are nature reserves and historical places. Thus, an increase in the duration of forest fires caused by global warming threatens the oldest UNESCO experts express concern about the fate of all these sites and urge national governments to develop more stringent environmental standards to protect nature and cultural monuments (Holleland et al, 2019).…”

La dinámica espacio-temporal del Patrimonio Mundial en Peligro

“…En conciencia con los cambios que acaecen en el planeta y las nuevas necesidades de la sociedad, la UNESCO creó la Lista del Patrimonio Mundial y una segunda Lista en Peligro para alertar de los que son receptores de algún tipo de amenaza contra su integridad, continuidad y conservación. La mayoría de los sitios tienen problemas relacionados con las actividades de uso del suelo (agricultura, minería o construcción), el desarrollo turístico, los conflictos armados, la gestión ineficiente de la administración o la corrupción, que son otros factores que causan el deterioro de los sitios (Caust y Vecco, 2017;Hølleland et al, 2019;Labadi, 2019).…”

World Heritage Sites and the question of scale in governance and politics: A study of Stonehenge

“… 24 Meskell 2012; Bertacchini, Liuzza, and Meskell 2017; Brown, Liuzza, and Meskell 2019; Hølleland Hamman, and Phelps 2019; Liuzza and Meskell 2023; Brumann and Gfeller 2022. …”