Eukaryotic RNA polymerase II and Escherichia coli RNA polymerase possess an intrinsic ribonuclease activity that is stimulated by the polymerase-binding proteins SII and GreB, respectively. This factor-activated hydrolysis of nascent RNA has been postulated to be involved in transcription elongation as well as removal of incorrect bases misincorporated into RNA. Little is known about the frequency of misincorporation by RNA polymerases in vivo or about the mechanisms involved in improving RNA polymerase accuracy. Here we have developed a luciferase reporter system in an effort to assay for base misincorporation in living Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The assay employs a luciferase open reading frame that contains a premature stop codon. The inactive truncated enzyme would become active if misincorporation by RNA polymerase II took place at the stop triplet. Yeast lacking SII did not display a significant change in reporter activity when compared with wild-type cells. We estimate that under our assay conditions, mRNAs with a misincorporation at the test site could not exceed 1 transcript per 500 cells. The reporter assay was very effective in detecting the previously described process of nonsense suppression (translational read-through) by ribosomes, making it difficult to determine an absolute level of basal (SII-independent) misincorporation by RNA polymerase II. Although these data cannot exclude the possibility that SII is involved in proofreading, they make it unlikely that such a contribution is physiologically significant, especially relative to the high frequency of translational errors.Many DNA polymerases contain a nuclease activity that allows them to excise, from newly replicated DNA, bases that are misincorporated with respect to Watson-Crick base pair rules. With the recognition that many, if not all, multisubunit DNA-dependent RNA polymerases contain a nuclease activity that operates on nascent RNA came the suggestion that RNA polymerases proofread RNA misincorporation events using this activity (1-3). For bacterial RNA polymerase, this nuclease activity is stimulated by small RNA polymerase-binding proteins called GreA and GreB (4). A similar activity in eukaryotic RNA polymerases is stimulated by a small RNA polymerase II-binding protein called SII (also known as TFIIS) that has been found in all eukaryotes so far investigated. The greA and greB genes are not essential for Escherichia coli; nor is the SII-encoding gene essential for Saccharomyces cerevisiae (5, 6). In vitro, these proteins can reactivate RNA polymerase enzymes that lapse into an elongation-incompetent form (7). They do so by activating cleavage of the nascent RNA chain by RNA polymerase. The vast majority of nascent RNA is assembled according to strict Watson-Crick base pairing rules. Hence, these proteins have been considered transcription elongation factors. In vivo evidence consistent with this role has been described (8 -14).In vitro, misincorporation of nucleotides into RNA by RNA polymerase can be detected by experimental manip...