Multivariate density model comparison for multi-site flood-risk rainfall in the French Mediterranean area

Abstract

The French Mediterranean area is subject to intense rainfall events which might cause flash floods, the main natural hazard in the area. Flood-risk rainfall is defined as rainfall with a high spatial average and encompasses rainfall which might lead to flash floods. We aim to compare eight multivariate density models for multi-site flood-risk rainfall. In particular, an accurate characterization of the spatial variability of flood-risk rainfall is crucial to help understand flash flood processes. Daily data from eight rain gauge stations at the Gardon at Anduze, a small Mediterranean catchment, are used in this work. Each multivariate density model is made of a combination of a marginal model and a dependence structure. Two marginal models are considered: the Gamma distribution (parametric) and the Log-Normal mixture (nonparametric). Four dependence structures are included in the comparison: Gaussian, Student t, Skew Normal and Skew t in increasing order of complexity. They possess a representative set of theoretical properties (symmetry/asymmetry and asymptotic dependence/independence). The multivariate models are compared in terms of three types of criteria: (1) separate evaluation of the goodness-of-fit of the margins and of the dependence structures, (2) model selection with a leave-one-out evaluation of the AndersonDarling and Cramer-Von Mises statistics and (3) comparison in terms of two hydrologically interpretable quantities (return periods of the spatial average and conditional probabilities of exceedances). The key outcome of the comparison is that the Skew Normal with the Log-Normal mixture margins outperform significantly the other models. The asymmetry introduced by the Skew Normal is an added-value with respect to the Gaussian. Therefore, the Gaussian dependence structure, although widely used in the literature, is not recommended for the data in this study. In contrast, the asymptotically dependent models did not provide a significant improvement over the asymptotically independent ones.

Copulas for hydroclimatic analysis: A practice‐oriented overview

“…However, unlike Gaussian bivariate distributions, the marginal variables can follow any distribution and are, thus, not limited to solely follow a Gaussian distribution. The Student-t copula is characterized by a greater modeling flexibility in terms of tail dependence (Carreau & Bouvier, 2016), which is enabled by an additional degree-of-freedom parameter compared to the Gaussian copula.…”

Study on the early warning and forecasting of flash floods in small watersheds based on the rainfall pattern of risk probability combination

“…Due to the randomness of rainfall, its distribution in time and space is not uniform, which has a great impact on hydrological simulation. Carreau et al (2016) used daily data from eight rain gauge stations in the Gardon River catchment in Anduze, France, to make an accurate characterization of the spatial variability of flood-risk rainfall. Zoccatelli et al (2010) used a spatial rainfall metric to clarify the dependence between spatial rainfall organization, basin morphology and runoff response.…”

Study on the Uncertainty of Critical Rainfall for Flash Floods in Small Watersheds Based on the Random Rainfall Pattern

“…Because of the random characteristic of rainfall, the spatial and temporal distribution of rainfall is not uniform, which enormously affects the simulation results of hydrological models. Many studies have investigated the influence of rainfall spatial distribution on hydrological models (Douinot et al, 2016;Carreau and Bouvier, 2016;Zoccatelli et al, 2010). However, the spatial size of a small watershed within a mountainous region is small, hence the rainfall temporal distribution is mainly considered in this study.…”