Multiple forms of discrimination and relationships with health and wellbeing: findings from national cross-sectional surveys in Aotearoa/New Zealand

Abstract

BackgroundThe complex ways in which experiences of discrimination are patterned in society, including the exposure of communities to multiple overlapping forms of discrimination within social systems of oppression, is increasingly recognised in the health sciences. However, research examining the impacts on health and contribution to racial/ethnic health inequities remains limited. This study aims to contribute to the field by exploring the prevalence and patterning of experience of multiple forms of discrimination in Aotearoa/New Zealand, and associations with health and wellbeing.MethodsThe study’s conceptual approach is informed by Kaupapa Māori theory, Ecosocial theory, Critical Race Theory and intersectionality. Data are from the 2008, 2010 and 2012 General Social Surveys (GSS), biennial nationally-representative surveys in Aotearoa/New Zealand. We examined patterning of forms of discrimination in the last 12 months and frequency of experiencing multiple forms of discrimination. We also looked at associations between experience of multiple discrimination and self-rated health, mental health (using SF12), and life satisfaction using logistic regression. We used random effects meta-analysis to produce pooled estimates drawing from all three survey instances.ResultsMāori, and people from Pacific and Asian ethnic groups, reported much higher prevalence of racial discrimination, were more likely to have any experience of discrimination, and were also more likely to experience multiple forms of discrimination, in the last year relative to respondents in the European/Other category. Discrimination was associated with poorer self-rated health, poorer mental health, and greater life dissatisfaction in unadjusted and adjusted estimates. Negative health impacts increased as the number of forms of discrimination experienced increased.ConclusionsDiscrimination impacts negatively on the health of indigenous peoples and those from minoritised ethnic groups in Aotearoa/New Zealand through higher exposure to racial discrimination, other forms of discrimination, and a greater likelihood of experiencing multiple forms of discrimination. This supports the need for research and interventions that more fully account for the multiple and interlocking ways in which discrimination impacts on health in racialised social hierarchies to maintain systems of privilege and oppression.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12939-018-0735-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Experience of racism and associations with unmet need and healthcare satisfaction: the 2011/12 adult New Zealand Health Survey

“…In addition, the measures used do not cover multiple or cumulative experiences of racism or experiences of other forms of discrimination over time, which we know are differentially distributed by ethnicity. 23,43 Finally, they are subject to other limitations of self-reporting experiences of racism for marginalised groups including difficulty recognising and naming racism, social desirability, and the impact of internalised racism on reporting. 44 An underestimation of experience of racism would also lead to underestimates for associations with negative measures of healthcare.…”

The culture conversation: Report from the 2nd Australasian ILC meeting—Auckland 2019

“…Research with Māori and whānau demonstrates how instead of engaging with nurses and health professionals who value a relational approach to healthcare delivery, they are frequently met with being treated differently from other patients and families and instead made to feel whakamā (feelings of embarrassment and shame) (Wepa, 2016; Wepa & Wilson, 2019; Wilson, 2008; Wilson & Barton, 2012). Māori also experiences higher levels of discrimination (Cormack, Stanley, & Harris, 2018; Harris et al., 2012a, 2012b). Such interactions lead to environments where Māori feel unwelcome, their interactions with health professionals are ineffective, not having their healthcare needs met, and they encounter racism and discrimination.…”

Struggling to be involved: An interprofessional approach to examine Maori whanau engagement with healthcare services

“…Māori experience persistent inequities in health status and quality of health care compared to other groups of people living in Aotearoa [3]. These inequities are complex and multifaceted, primarily influenced by the disparities Māori have in access to the socio-economic determinants of health, differential access to health services and differences in quality of care [4][5][6]. Māori report struggling to have their cultural needs met when they engage with health services, particularly about the inclusion of their whānau and ensuring the wellbeing of their wairua (spirit).…”

“…Most literature focuses on barriers to accessing health care for Māori, related to higher levels of socio-economic deprivation and lower health status [10]. More recent literature highlights the role of racism Māori encounter, and its affects on their healthcare experiences and health outcomes [4,5]. Despite the importance of whānau in Māori health and wellbeing, little research exists about whānau perspectives of their engagement with healthcare services when supporting an unwell or ill whānau member.…”