Purpose: IFN-a is administered to melanoma patients and its endogenous production is essential for immune-mediated tumor recognition. We hypothesized that a reduced capacity for signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT) 1activation allows melanoma cells to evade the direct actions of IFN-a. Experimental Design: Tyr 701 -phosphorylated STAT1 (P-STAT1) was measured by flow cytometry in IFN-a^stimulated human melanoma cell lines, melanoma cells derived from patient tumors, and peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC). Expression of other Janusactivated kinase (Jak)-STAT intermediates (STAT1, STAT2, Jak1, tyrosine kinase 2, IFN-a receptor, STAT3, and STAT5) was evaluated by flow cytometry, immunoblot, or immunohistochemistry. Results: Significant variability in P-STAT1was observed in human melanoma cell lines following IFN-a treatment (P < 0.05) and IFN-a^induced P-STAT1 correlated with the antiproliferative effects of IFN-a (P = 0.042). Reduced formation of P-STAT1 was not explained by loss of Jak-STAT proteins or enhanced STAT5 signaling as reported previously. Basal levels of P-STAT3 were inversely correlated with IFN-a^induced P-STAT1in cell lines (P = 0.013). IFN-a^induced formation of P-STAT1was also variable in melanoma cells derived from patient tumors; however, no relationship between P-STAT3 and IFN-a^induced P-STAT1 was evident. Because IFN-a acts on both tumor and immune cells, we examined the ability of IFN-a to induce P-STAT1 in patient-derived melanoma cells and PBMCs. IFN-a induced significantly lower levels of P-STAT1 in melanoma cells compared with matched PBMCs (P = 0.046). Melanoma cells and human melanocytes required 10-fold higher IFN-a doses to exert P-STAT1 levels comparable with PBMCs. Conclusions: Melanoma cells are variable in their IFN-a responsiveness, and cells of the melanocytic lineage exhibit a lower capacity for IFN-a^induced Jak-STAT signaling compared with immune cells.