Moving beyond Curve Fitting: Using Complementary Data to Assess Alternative Explanations for Long Movements of Three Vulture Species

Abstract

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.. abstract: Animal movements exhibit an almost universal pattern of fat-tailed step-size distributions, mixing short and very long steps. The Lévy flight foraging hypothesis (LFFH) suggests a single optimal food search strategy to explain this pattern, yet mixed movement distributions are biologically more plausible and often convincingly fit movement data. To confront alternative explanations for these patterns, we tracked vultures of three species in two very different ecosystems using high-resolution global positioning system/accelerometer tags accompanied by behavioral, genetic, and morphological data. The Lévy distribution fitted the data sets reasonably well, matching expectations based on their sparsely distributed food resources; yet the fit of mixed models was considerably better, suggesting distinct movement modes operating at three different scales. Specifically, long-range forays (LRFs)-rare, short-term, large-scale circular journeys that greatly exceed the typical foraging range and contribute to the tail-fatness of the movement distribution in all three speciesdo not match an optimal foraging strategy suggested by the LFFH. We also found no support for preferred weather conditions or population genetic structure as alternative explanations, so the hypothesis that LRFs represent failed breeding dispersal attempts to find mates remains our most plausible explanation at this time. We conclude that inference about the mechanisms underlying animal movements should be confronted with complementary data, and suggest that mixed behavioral modes likely explain commonly observed fat-tailed movement distributions.

Social foraging and individual consistency in following behaviour: testing the information centre hypothesis in free-ranging vultures

“…Eurasian griffon vultures can be considered as partial migrants during the first years of life, becoming mostly sedentary after first breeding, though some adults eventually engage in long-range forays presumably reflecting unsuccessful breeding attempts [36,37]. These two movement phenomena that are characterized by directional movements between geographically separated regions were grouped in our analysis under long-range movements.…”

Socially interacting or indifferent neighbours? Randomization of movement paths to tease apart social preference and spatial constraints

“…; Spiegel et al . ) allows researchers to develop more appropriate null models for expected association rates (e.g. based on heterogeneous HR use), which then can be compared to the empirical observations.…”

Short-term effects of tagging on activity and movement patterns of Eurasian beavers (Castor fiber)

“…These tags can be equipped with a suite of sensors related to animal state, such as heart beat frequency and/or body temperature (Butler et al 2004;Evans et al 2016;Friebe et al 2014), but may also document movement patterns (Rhodes et al 2005;Zimmermann et al 2007), general activity, behaviour and proxies for energy expenditure (Shepard et al 2008;. Such tags can be used under challenging environmental conditions, including aquatic (Gleiss et al 2011;Thorrold et al 2014) and terrestrial habitats (Steyaert et al 2014;Williams et al 2014), as well as on species that spend a considerable amount of their time in air (Nathan et al 2012;Spiegel et al 2015). The general premise is that such tags allow free-living animals to be studied with Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s10344-016-1051-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.…”