Movement visualisation in virtual reality rehabilitation of the lower limb: a systematic review

Abstract

BackgroundVirtual reality (VR) based applications play an increasing role in motor rehabilitation. They provide an interactive and individualized environment in addition to increased motivation during motor tasks as well as facilitating motor learning through multimodal sensory information. Several previous studies have shown positive effect of VR-based treatments for lower extremity motor rehabilitation in neurological conditions, but the characteristics of these VR applications have not been systematically investigated. The visual information on the user’s movement in the virtual environment, also called movement visualisation (MV), is a key element of VR-based rehabilitation interventions. The present review proposes categorization of Movement Visualisations of VR-based rehabilitation therapy for neurological conditions and also summarises current research in lower limb application.MethodsA systematic search of literature on VR-based intervention for gait and balance rehabilitation in neurological conditions was performed in the databases namely; MEDLINE (Ovid), AMED, EMBASE, CINAHL, and PsycInfo. Studies using non-virtual environments or applications to improve cognitive function, activities of daily living, or psychotherapy were excluded. The VR interventions of the included studies were analysed on their MV.ResultsIn total 43 publications were selected based on the inclusion criteria. Seven distinct MV groups could be differentiated: indirect MV (N = 13), abstract MV (N = 11), augmented reality MV (N = 9), avatar MV (N = 5), tracking MV (N = 4), combined MV (N = 1), and no MV (N = 2). In two included articles the visualisation conditions included different MV groups within the same study. Additionally, differences in motor performance could not be analysed because of the differences in the study design. Three studies investigated different visualisations within the same MV group and hence limited information can be extracted from one study.ConclusionsThe review demonstrates that individuals’ movements during VR-based motor training can be displayed in different ways. Future studies are necessary to fundamentally explore the nature of this VR information and its effect on motor outcome.

Principles of Neurorehabilitation After Stroke Based on Motor Learning and Brain Plasticity Mechanisms

“…Biofeedback uses physiological sources like electromyograms to provide patients with real-time visual or auditory signals about their motor activity (Huang et al, 2006). Ultimately arm movements can be visualized and augmented using VR representations (Ballester Rubio et al, 2015b;Ferreira dos Santos et al, 2016).…”

The Effect of a Virtual No-Step Zone on Balance Control in Walking

“…Previous research has shown motor adaptation in upper limb experiments in the presence of an avatar (Bourdin et al, 2019). However, studies about gait kinematics are still needed to understand the specific components of virtual reality immersion and their possible benefits (Ferreira dos Santos et al, 2015).…”

Technische Entwicklungen zur Rehabilitation der Mobilität

“…B. Hinweise, dass die bewegungssynchrone Darstellung eines Körpers in virtueller Umgebung (Avatar) zusätzliche Effekte bewirkt, die über den rein motivationalen Aspekt einer spielerischen Umgebung mit Zielerreichung hinausgeht. Erste Ansätze einer Klassifizierung der verschiedenen Umgebungen wurden vorgestellt [26]. Insgesamt muss davor gewarnt werden, dass "bunter" und "ausgefeilter" gerade bei kognitiv eingeschränkten Patienten nicht unbedingt auch besser wirksam sein muss.…”