Mount Pinatubo, Inflammatory Cytokines, and the Immunological Ecology of Aeta Hunter-Gatherers

Abstract

Early growth cessation and reproduction are predicted to maximize fitness under conditions of high adult mortality, factors that could explain the pygmy phenotype of many rainforest hunter-gatherers. This lifehistory hypothesis is elegant but contentious in part because it lacks a clear biological mechanism. One mechanism stems from the field of human immunological ecology and the concept of inflammation "memory" across the life cycle and into subsequent generations. Maternal exposures to disease can infl uence immunological cues present in breast milk; because maternal provisioning via lactation occurs during critical periods of development, it is plausible that these cues can also mediate early growth cessation and small body size. Such epigenetic hypotheses are difficult to test, but the concept of developmental programming is attractive because it could explain how the stature of a population can change over time, in terms of both secular increases and rapid intergenerational decreases. Here we explore this concept by focusing on the Aeta, a population of former hunter-gatherers, and the Ilocano, a population of rice farmers. We predicted that Aeta mothers would produce breast milk with higher concentrations of four bioactive factors due to high infectious burdens. Further, we predicted that the concentrations of these factors would be highest in the cohort of women born in the early 1990s, when exposure to infectious disease was acute following the eruption of Mount Pinatubo in June 1991. We analyzed levels of adiponectin, C-reactive protein, and epidermal growth factor in the milk of 24 Aeta and 31 Ilocano women and found no detectable differences, whereas levels of transforming growth factor-β 2 were elevated among the Aeta, particularly as a function of maternal age. We found no difference between cohorts divided by the volcanic eruption (n = 43 born before, n = 12 born after). We discuss the implications of our findings for the terminal investment hypothesis and we suggest that the historical ecology of the Aeta is a promising model system for testing epigenetic hypotheses focused on the evolution of small body size. Abstract Early growth cessation and reproduction are predicted to maximize fitness under conditions of high adult mortality, factors that could explain the pygmy phenotype of many rainforest hunter-gatherers. This life-history hypothesis is elegant but contentious in part because it lacks a clear biological mechanism. One mechanism stems from the field of human immunological ecology and the concept of inflammation "memory" across the life cycle and into subsequent generations. Maternal exposures to disease can infl uence immunological cues present in breast milk; because maternal provisioning via lactation occurs during critical periods of development, it is plausible that these cues can also mediate early growth cessation and small body size. Such epigenetic hypotheses are difficult to test, but the concept of developmental programming is attractive because it could explain how the...

Patterns of milk macronutrients and bioactive molecules across lactation in a western lowland gorilla (Gorilla gorilla) and a Sumatran orangutan (Pongo abelii)

“…Milk EGF concentrations in this study were highest in gorilla milk (29.7 ± 0.9 ng/ml), followed by orangutan (7.8 ± 0.4 ng/ml); these EGF concentrations are all below those found in mature human milk from western women (75 ± 12 ng/ml; Dvorak, Fituch, Williams, Hurst, & Schanler, ), but similar to values found in milk from women in rural Philippines (18.1 ± 0.8 ng/ml; Bernstein & Dominy, ). The mid‐lactation gorilla milk sample contained low concentrations of TFG‐β2 (0.7 ± 0.1 ng/ml) compared to human values from western and rural Philippine women (median of 3.6 ng/ml and mean of 3.2 ± 0.5 ng/ml, respectively).…”

Ecological immunity of human milk: Life history perspectives from the United States and Kenya

“…There was a non‐significant trend in the expected direction in TGF‐β2 levels, with a lower geometric mean in the milk of mothers with diagnosed allergies (43% of sample, 625.7 pg/mL) than those without diagnosed allergies (823.0 pg/mL). The mean TGF‐β2 milk of Kenyan mothers in this study was lower than any of the means reported in Oddy and Rosales (), as well as several other publications with non‐Western and/or rural populations (Bernstein & Dominy, ; Holmlund et al, ; Ruiz et al, ; Tomicic et al, ). Bernstein and Dominy () attribute higher levels of TGF‐β2 in milk to greater history of exposure to infectious pathogens, although lack of pathogen exposure is not likely in Kenya (unpublished data show a high proportion of women with high C‐reactive protein values, but these values are not associated with milk TGF‐β2).…”

“…The mean TGF‐β2 milk of Kenyan mothers in this study was lower than any of the means reported in Oddy and Rosales (), as well as several other publications with non‐Western and/or rural populations (Bernstein & Dominy, ; Holmlund et al, ; Ruiz et al, ; Tomicic et al, ). Bernstein and Dominy () attribute higher levels of TGF‐β2 in milk to greater history of exposure to infectious pathogens, although lack of pathogen exposure is not likely in Kenya (unpublished data show a high proportion of women with high C‐reactive protein values, but these values are not associated with milk TGF‐β2). One possibility could be that a women's experiences in Kenya, whether it is disease load or specific pathogen, an environmental exposure such as animal contact or water supply, or marginalized status in the region, or poverty, is contributing to low TGF‐β in their milk.…”

Milk at altitude: Human milk macronutrient composition in a high‐altitude adapted population of tibetans

“…Among humans, maternal milk synthesis is adequate even under conditions of severe malnutrition, although volume may be compromised (Jelliffe and Jelliffe, ). Maternal somatic buffering appears to only apply to milk macronutrients and to a lesser extent volume; there is considerable documented global variation in milk fatty acids, micronutrients, hormones, and immune factors reflecting dietary or ecological pressures (Bernstein and Dominy, ; Butte et al, ; Insull et al, ; Ley et al, ; Miller and McConnell, ; Prentice, ; Quinn et al, ; Santos et al, ; Savino and Liguori, ; Smit et al, ).…”