More than 100 point mutations of the superoxide scavenger Cu͞Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD; EC 1.15.1.1) have been associated with the neurodegenerative disease amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). However, these mutations are scattered throughout the protein and provide no clear functional or structural clues to the underlying disease mechanism. Therefore, we undertook to look for foldingrelated defects by comparing the unfolding behavior of five ALS-associated mutants with distinct structural characteristics: A4V at the interface between the N and C termini, C6F in the hydrophobic core, D90A at the protein surface, and G93A and G93C, which decrease backbone flexibility. With the exception of the disruptive replacements A4V and C6F, the mutations only marginally affect the stability of the native protein, yet all mutants share a pronounced destabilization of the metal-free apo state: the higher the stability loss, the lower the mean survival time for ALS patients carrying the mutation. Thus organism-level pathology may be directly related to the properties of the immature state of a protein rather than to those of the native species.A myotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a motor neuron syndrome where a sub group of 3-6% has been associated with a diverse set of mutations in the superoxide scavenger Cu͞Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD; 1.15.1.1) (1, 2). Interestingly, several of these mutations show perfectly native-like in vivo activity (3, 4) and metal coordination (5). As an alternative cause of disease, transgenic mouse models suggest that ALS arises through an adverse, and yet-unidentified, side reaction of the mutated protein causing cytotoxicity. Mice devoid of SOD retain normal motor function (6), as do mice overexpressing wild-type SOD. In contrast, mice expressing high levels of mutant human SOD in addition to endogenous SOD show neural damage. The collective evidence suggests that mutant SOD has gained a cytopathogenic function (7,8). Models for how the neurodegenerating toxicity arise include the following: (i) enzymatic side-reactions in catalytically promiscuous SOD mutants producing increased levels of oxidative compounds such as hydroxyl radicals (9-11) and peroxynitrite (12), (ii) release of free Cu ions (13), (iii) aberrant binding of SOD to other proteins (14), (iv) binding of mutant SOD to heat shock proteins (15, 16) with the subsequent prevention of their antiapoptotic function (16), (v) altered redox regulation (17), and (vi) formation of toxic SOD aggregates (18)(19)(20). Evidence that could potentially distinguish between these models was recently provided from mice lacking the metal-loading chaperone CCS (copper chaperone for SOD; ref. 21). The chaperone is essential for incorporating the copper ion and, hence, to gain the native protein. When the CCS gene was ablated, the ALS-associated mutations were observed to still provoke the disease, indicating that a copper-free precursor state of SOD causes neurotoxicity (21). Along this line, a broad spectrum of mechanistic scenarios is implicated...