Proprioceptive information, originating from the locomotor system makes us able to perceive the position of our joints from an internal point of view. In certain cases, proprioceptive information has to be stored in short-term memory, for example, during the learning of new motor skills or the assessment of proprioceptive accuracy. However, there are contradictory findings about the modality-specific storage of proprioceptive information in working memory. In this preregistered study, we applied the interference paradigm, assessing proprioceptive memory capacity in the subdominant elbow joint for 35 young individuals in five different experimental conditions: (a) without competing task/suppression (control condition), (b) with motor suppression, (c) with spatial suppression, (d) with visual suppression, and (e) with verbal suppression. Proprioceptive span was lower in the verbal and spatial suppression condition than in the control condition, whereas no differences were found for the remaining conditions. These results indicate that individuals use verbal and spatial strategies to encode proprioceptive information in short-term memory, and, in contrast to our expectation, the motor subsystem of working memory is not involved in this process.