Motivational determinants among physicians in Lahore, Pakistan

Abstract

IntroductionHuman resource crises in developing countries have been identified as a critical aspect of poor quality and low accessibility in health care. Worker motivation is an important facet of this issue. Specifically, motivation among physicians, who are an important bridge between health systems and patients, should be considered. This study aimed to identify the determinants of job motivation among physicians, a neglected perspective, especially in developing countries.MethodsA stratified random sample of 360 physicians was selected from public primary, public secondary and public and private tertiary health facilities in the Lahore district, Pakistan. Pretested, semi-structured, self-administered questionnaires were used. For the descriptive part of this study, physicians were asked to report their 5 most important work motivators and demotivators within the context of their current jobs and in general. Responses were coded according to emergent themes and frequencies calculated. Of the 30 factors identified, 10 were classified as intrinsic, 16 as organizational and 4 as socio-cultural.ResultsIntrinsic and socio-cultural factors like serving people, respect and career growth were important motivators. Conversely, demotivators across setups were mostly organizational, especially in current jobs. Among these, less pay was reported the most frequently. Fewer opportunities for higher qualifications was a demotivator among primary and secondary physicians. Less personal safety and poor working conditions were important in the public sector, particularly among female physicians. Among private tertiary physicians financial incentives other than pay and good working conditions were motivators in current jobs. Socio-cultural and intrinsic factors like less personal and social time and the inability to financially support oneself and family were more important among male physicians.ConclusionMotivational determinants differed across different levels of care, sectors and genders. Nonetheless, the important motivators across setups in this study were mostly intrinsic and socio-cultural, which are difficult to affect while the demotivators were largely organizational. Many can be addressed even at the facility level such as less personal safety and poor working conditions. Thus, in resource limited settings a good strategic starting point could be small scale changes that may markedly improve physicians' motivation and subsequently the quality of health care.

Motivation and Retention of Physicians in Primary Healthcare Facilities: A Qualitative Study From Abbottabad, Pakistan

“…This was because it was inconvenient to travel to the rural health facilities as most of them resided in cities. 36 Relocation to rural posts was even more difficulty for the female physicians. Many also experienced cultural restrictions and taboos to work in communities other than their own.…”

“…On the contrary frequent shift work is related with stress which results from lack of satisfaction and high job turnover among healthcare providers. 36,38 Respect given to physicians by the patients motivated physicians in this study. A healthy doctor-patient relationship was necessary and of paramount importance to the satisfaction of physicians.…”

To Ban or Not to Ban? Regulating Dual Practice in Palestine

“…33,34 Improving intrinsic motivators and working conditions will be important to ensure success of the reforms, recognizing that the political and financial circumstances will make the latter challenging. Both Turkish and French experiences demonstrate the importance of investing in the public sector, in terms of enhancing working conditions, accountability, and professional development opportunities in luring physicians back to full-time practice.…”

Migration of International Medical Graduates: Implications for the Brain-Drain

“…The result is a debilitating brain drain. The migration of physicians from the poor to the rich countries has contributed immensely to the growing health-workforce crisis in the developing world [4].…”

“…South Asia and Africa also bear the greatest burden of disease. Sub-Saharan Africa and South-east Asia together have 53 percent of the global disease burden but only 15 percent of the "world's healthcare workforce" [4].…”