Motivation and barriers to access to formal credit of primary cinnamon producers from the perspective of value chain development in Northwestern Vietnam

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to investigate borrowing motivation, credit access barriers and their impacts on income of smallholder farmers engaging in cinnamon value chain development in Northwestern Vietnam. Design/methodology/approach A multistage sampling technique using a structural questionnaire and in-depth interviews was applied for collecting primary data from farmers and relevant stakeholders. The Propensity Score Matching was employed to analyze access barriers and examine whether relaxing these barriers can improve farmer income. To deal with the issue of model uncertainty and further increase the robustness of results, Bayesian model average and the bootstrapping approach were applied. Findings To fulfill the certain quality standards of cinnamon products which are later used in the medicinal and food industry, farmers as primary producers need credit for intensive investment to increase the value of their products. Still, there are 25.36 percent of farmers who have access constraints to formal credit. In the credit received group, 24.56 percent have not received full credit as demanded. Access problems are relevant to lack of collateral, lack of bank account holdings, inconvenient access to roads, weak chain linkage and limited organic farming. Removing credit access barriers can improve the income for farmers from cinnamon farming activities. Research limitations/implications More detailed information on the conditions under which credit serves a more important role in creating value addition for cinnamon products can help the government establish more effective credit policies. Social implications Great attention should be paid to smallholder farmers as primary producers in the chain for sustainable value chain development in developing and emerging economies. Policy interventions should facilitate access to bank accounts, speed up the process of granting residential land use certificates, certify organic farming and upgrade the road system. Strengthening the chain linkage can enhance smallholder farmers’ capacity to obtain credit through value chain lending development. Originality/value Empirical studies on agricultural credit from the perspective of value chain development remain scarce. A better understanding of credit access constraints allows for the positing of recommendations for policy makers to facilitate value chain lending and a medicinal plant-based agro-forestry system in similar situations.

The impact of the Vietnam Bank for Social Policies preferential credit on household welfare in Vietnam: a panel data analysis

“…If the bank coverage is expanded, it would give clients a better access to the credit and reduce the impact of “black credit”. This barrier is almost similar to what Luan (2019) and Beck et al (2005) found. The results show that the loan volume is sufficient (2 = sufficient) and meets demand of the borrowers.…”

“…Johnston and Morduch (2008) found that distance could be a barrier for clients to access bank savings services in Mexico. Luan (2019) identified barriers of accessing formal credit of cinnamon growers in the Northwest of Vietnam included lack of collateral, bank accounts and geographical difficulties.…”

The Effects of Services by Microfinance Institutions on the Welfare of Urban Households in Malaysia

“…While Teng et al (2011) evaluated the positive effect of microcredit on welfare of low-income households, Phan et al (2019) found an insignificant effect. A similar study has also shown that welfare does not appear to be driven by microcredit (Luan 2019). The study strongly stated that the provision of microcredit was able to enhance the financial status, health status and also education level of the low-income households.…”

Market-oriented extension and farming efficiency in small-scale maize farmers: evidence from Northern Vietnam

“…The result suggested that PVS practically stimulated the participation and adoption of the attending farmers to the local market to purchase new seed varieties. Micro-credit, another form of government intervention, was also verified to significantly impact the approaching capability of Northwestern Vietnamese farmers in the study of (Luan, 2019). Consequently, market-access orientation has become a substantially irreplaceable content in extension training courses that directly support farmers to do their agribusiness sustainably by enhancing their pre-and post-harvest activities.…”