Mothers, Maids and Tutors: An Empirical Evaluation of their Effect on Children's Academic Grades in Singapore

Abstract

As female labour force participation in the workforce increases in Singapore, the basic economic unit—the home—has become wealthier, although arguably at the expense of both personal and family leisure. Yet with additional income, breadwinners are better able to undertake investment for their own well-being or their children's well-being that can offset the net loss of utility associated with less leisure. Concomitantly, it is common to find a domestic helper living with a Singapore family and other specialist helpers such as paid home tutors, who come to the home. This paper examines how this new investment vis-a-vis new home variables affects a child's overall academic performance. Primarily, the effects of a mother's choice to work, the presence of either tutors or domestic helpers and the effects of different investment strategies to raise a child's qualitative attributes. The paper asserts that how a child performs academically is less dependent on his/her choice of time use; rather, it is the number of qualitative benefits the child receives in the home environment. The conventional wisdom of 'the more the better' is questioned by the results of this study, arguing instead that diminishing returns set in far quicker when over-investment in the child takes place.Academic performance, domestic helper, Singapore, tutors, simultaneous equation probit model,

The Role of Social Support in Dance Talent Development

“…Mr. Tan's support of Feng's choice for ballet over academic studies and his belief in her potential were paramount in the way he recommended strategic (e.g., locating the best dance schools) and difficult decisions (e.g., Feng gave up a place at the prestigious School of the Arts in Singapore) for Feng's development. His support resembles that of the parents of a musically talented Singaporean adolescent (Ho & Chong, 2010), but contradicts the findings that Singaporean parents placed emphasis on their children's academic achievements over the arts (Cheo & Quah, 2005;Garces-Bacsal, 2013b). "[I told Feng] 'Perhaps you should forget about your studies,'" said Mr. Tan, "I want her to focus right now just on ballet because if you focus on something at a time, then you can achieve something.…”

English-Speaking Foreign Domestic Helpers and Students' English Reading Attainment in Hong Kong

“…Many working mothers resort to a replacement form of maternal care (Gershuny and Robinson 1988;Sanik 1981), one form of which is the employment of a domestic helper to live with the family, carry out household chores, and look after the children (Chant and Mcllwaine 1995). Cheo and Quah (2005) investigated the impact of domestic helpers on students' academic performance in Singapore and found that, even though working mothers made explicit demands on such workers intended to benefit their children's academic performance, the impact on the child's academic attainment of employing a domestic helper was insignificant. Hong Kong differs from Singapore in that English is the students' second language, whereas English is the mother tongue of the students in Singapore.…”

Does private tutoring increase students’ academic performance? Evidence from Turkey

“…Other studies indicated either no impact or even a negative impact of private tutoring on academic performance (Suryadarma et al 2006;Cheo and Quah 2005). In a third set of studies, the impact of private tutoring was found to be related to the fields of competence.…”