Mosque as a multi-functional public space destination: potential breathing space in dense urban fabrics of Hail City, Saudi Arabia

Abstract

PurposeThe general concept of public space in Saudi Arabia is relatively recent; it is the result of an attempt to modernize several conservative traditions and norms, as well as the ambitious vision of 2030, which reprioritized Saudi cities' public spaces by implementing a quality-of-life improvement program. This study aims to investigate the relationship between mosque location and surrounding urban context as a significant urban design issue in order to comprehend the potential for transforming such an element into a multifunctional public space destination in a dense urban fabric.Design/methodology/approachThe study's objectives are divided into two areas: a spatial configuration analysis to examine the urban context and an urban analysis of the mosque site with a study area boundary of a 400-m buffer zone. Quantitative and qualitative methodologies were utilized; in addition, a user feedback survey was conducted in which several key insights were compiled, such as the importance of safety urban element factors, aesthetic elements and green areas in the built environment in making mosques places that are active public spaces.FindingsThe study’s main finding encourages governmental institutions to change their mindset from “open space around the mosque” to “the mosque as an element within public space,” which will have a significant impact on how the authors approach, improve and redevelop existing mosque locations. Several concepts were presented that should be reconsidered and redeveloped in order to align with the most recent sustainable urban design tools; the mosque to be overlooked as a community gathering place rather than just a place for religious rituals.Research limitations/implicationsThis study is limited to sacred mosque sites primarily found in Islamic countries; it focuses on Saudi Arabian urban and planning practices in relation to sociocultural norms. The authors believe that increasing the number of study samples or broadening the scope of the study to include other Saudi regions or other Middle Eastern countries could yield new findings and insights.Originality/valueThe study offers a conceptual design model based on survey results and qualitative analysis and recommending strategies that planners, designers and policymakers can use to design successful mosque places and pedestrian-oriented developments.

Kuwait's circular prototype mosque design: a history and comprehensive evaluation

“…The data analysis revealed that the circular mosque prototype has three main areas with shortcomings: planning failure, design failure and implementation and construction failure. First and foremost, a mosque should serve as a symbolic and active public space for the community (Alnaim and Noaime, 2022). However, it is evident from Figures 3 and 4-A, 4-C that the circular prototype does not integrate well with the surrounding urban context.…”

Practical Exploration of the Integration of Eco-Art and Social Participatory Design in the Transformation of Public Space

“…(4) Focus on comprehensiveness: Ecological art and socially engaged design emphasize comprehensiveness, signifying that design considerations extend beyond individual public spaces to encompass the entire city and other relevant factors. Therefore, in the process of public space transformation, it is necessary to initiate from city-wide planning and actual circumstances, incorporate multiple interests, coordinate various resources, and develop different transformation plans based on different spatial areas, achieving overall harmony in the public spaces [3].…”

Examining the complexities of estate management practices in Central mosques: a case study of Kumasi Central mosque in Ghana

“…Consequently, we have observed the proliferation of central mosques across Ghana, but a persistent dearth of individuals capable of effectively administering these religious institutions remains. According to Allia et al (2013), effective management of the mosque plays a crucial role in ensuring the successful provision of services to the public (Alnaim and Noaime, 2023). Hence, it is imperative for a mosque to have efficient and meticulously structured management strategies.…”