The
influence of ytterbium ions (Yb3+), a
commonly used
paramagnetic NMR chemical shift reagent, on the physical properties
and flip-flop kinetics of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC)
planar supported lipid bilayers (PSLBs) was investigated. Langmuir
isotherm studies revealed that Yb3+ interacts strongly
with the phosphate headgroup of DPPC, evidenced by the increases in
shear and compression moduli. Using sum-frequency vibrational spectroscopy,
changes in the acyl chain ordering and phase transition temperature
were also observed, consistent with Yb3+ interacting with
the phosphate headgroup of DPPC. The changes in the physical properties
of the membrane were also observed to be concentration dependent,
with more pronounced modification observed at low (50 μM) Yb3+ concentrations compared to 6.5 mM Tb3+, suggesting
a cross-linking mechanism between adjacent DPPC lipids. Additionally,
the changes in membrane packing and phase transition temperatures
in the presence of Tris buffer suggested that a putative Yb(Tris)3+ complex forms that coordinates to the PC headgroup. The
kinetics of DPPC flip-flop in the gel and liquid crystalline (lc)
phases were substantially inhibited in the presence of Yb3+, regardless of the Yb3+ concentration. Analysis of the
flip-flop kinetics under the framework of transition state theory
revealed that the free energy barrier to flip-flop in both the gel
and lc phases was substantial increased over a pure DPPC membrane.
In the gel phase, the trend in the free energy barrier appeared to
follow the trend in the shear moduli, suggesting that the Yb3+–DPPC headgroup interaction was driving the increase in the
activation free energy barrier. In the lc phase, activation free energies
of DPPC flip-flop in the presence of 50 μM or 6.5 mM Yb3+ were found to mirror the free energies of TEMPO–DPPC
flip-flop, leading to the conclusion that the strong interaction between
Yb3+ and the PC headgroup was essentially manifested as
a headgroup charge modification. These studies illustrate that the
presence of the lanthanide Yb3+ results in significant
modification to the lipid membrane physical properties and, more importantly,
results in a pronounced inhibition of native lipid flip-flop.