Groundwater ecosystems are globally widespread yet still poorly understood. We investigated the age, aqueous geochemistry, and microbiology of 138 groundwater samples from 87 monitoring wells (<250m depth) located in 14 aquifers in the Canadian Prairie. Geochemistry and microbial ecology were tightly linked revealing large-scale aerobic and anaerobic hydrogen, methane, nitrogen, and sulfur cycling carried out by diverse microbial communities. Older groundwaters contained on average more cells (up to 1.4×107/mL) than younger groundwaters. Organic carbon-rich strata featured some of the highest abundances, challenging current estimates of global groundwater population sizes. Substantial concentrations of dissolved oxygen (n=57; 0.52±0.12 mg/L [mean ± SE]; 0.39 mg/L [median]) in older groundwaters could support aerobic lifestyles in subsurface ecosystems at an unprecedented scale. Metagenomics, oxygen isotope analyses and mixing models indicated that microbial ″dark oxygen″ contributed to the dissolved oxygen pool in subsurface ecosystems commonly assumed to be anoxic.